| Description | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Young Hollywood star and student at Miss Robichaux's Academy | Madison Montgomery | 93%
|
| Headmistress of Miss Robichaux's Academy and daughter of the current Supreme | Cordelia Foxx | 89%
|
| Supreme witch of her generation and mother of #1 | Fiona Goode | 89%
|
| Witch with the power to bring souls back from the dead brought to Miss Robichaux's Academy after surviving being burned alive | Misty Day | 89%
|
| Shy, young girl who discovers that she is a witch and is whisked off to Miss Robichaux's Academy | Zoe Benson | 89%
|
| Human voodoo-doll from Detroit enrolled at Miss Robichaux's Academy | Queenie | 88%
|
| Friendly college student and fraternity leader that is brought back to life by the witches after a bus "accident" | Kyle Spencer | 83%
|
| Eccentric but dedicated head of the Witches' Council | Myrtle Snow | 81%
|
| The Immortal Queen of Voodoo | Marie Laveau | 79%
|
| Enigmatic young witch at Miss Robichaux's Academy with the power of clairvoyance | Nan | 79%
|
| New Orleans socialite from the 1830's that tortured and murdered her slaves, given eternal life and buried alive, but rediscovered in 2013 by the witches | Delphine LaLaurie | 74%
|
| Axe-wielding serial killer that terrorized New Orleans in the 1910's | The Axeman | 67%
|
| Mute butler of Miss Robichaux's Academy | Spalding | 64%
|
| Voodoo Gatekeeper of the Spirit World that balances the scales of life and death | Papa Legba | 61%
|
| Handsome son of ^ that moves in next door to Miss Robichaux's Academy | Luke Ramsey | 46%
|
| Supposedly #1's supporting husband, but in reality a witch-hunter hired by #10 | Hank Foxx | 44%
|
| Tortured slave of #8 that had the head of a bull put onto his body, kept alive by #10 in the present day | The Minotaur | 36%
|
| Fundamentalist Christian that moves in next door to Miss Robichaux's Academy | Joan Ramsey | 27%
|