| Description | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Ghostly leader of the Lost Colony of Roanoke that haunts the Roanoke House | The Butcher | 89%
|
| Yoga teacher that moves from Los Angeles to the Roanoke House in North Carolina after a trauma | Shelby Miller | 80%
|
| Rational pharmaceutical salesman that moves to the Roanoke House with ^ after surviving a coma due to a gang initiation | Matt Miller | 79%
|
| Former no-nonsense police officer and sister of #3 struggling with sobriety | Lee Harris | 71%
|
| English actress that plays #2 in "My Roanoke Nightmare" obsessed with her own age | Audrey Tindall | 70%
|
| Laidback actor married to #5 that plays #21 in "My Roanoke Nightmare" | Rory Monahan | 68%
|
| Insane actress that plays #1 in "My Roanoke Nightmare" that became psychotic after becoming obsessed with the ghost she played | Agnes Mary Winstead | 61%
|
| Immoral lead producer of "My Roanoke Nightmare" | Sidney Aaron James | 57%
|
| Cruel matriarch of the cannibalistic Polk family | Mama Polk | 55%
|
| Wealthy aristocratic nobleman that constructed the Roanoke House in the late 1700's | Edward Philippe Mott | 54%
|
| Adventurous daughter of #10 and ^ | Flora Harris | 54%
|
| Ambitious actor that plays ^ in "My Roanoke Nightmare" willing to do immoral things to get the fame he so desperately wants | Dominic Banks | 48%
|
| Sassy actress that plays ^ in "My Roanoke Nightmare" that becomes an alcoholic after playing her | Monet Tumusiime | 45%
|
| Disturbing ghost with the severed head of a pig on his head that haunts the Roanoke House and it's lands | Piggy Man | 41%
|
| Ex-husband of #10 whose patience has a very low threshold | Mason Harris | 39%
|
| Flamboyant medium from New Orleans that helps #10 find her missing daughter | Cricket Marlowe | 36%
|
| Young girl that was sacrificed by #1 in the 1500's that benevolently haunts the Roanoke House | Priscilla | 34%
|
| Empathetic cannibalistic member of the Polk family | Jether Polk | 29%
|
| Academic and aspiring author investigating the haunted Roanoke House and the mysterious disappearances within | Elias Cunningham | 25%
|
| Bloodthirsty immortal witch and the first Supreme that came to America in the 1500's | Scáthach | 25%
|
| Actor that plays #7 in "My Roanoke Nightmare" that served two tours in Afghanistan | Dylan | 23%
|
| Son of #1 and reluctant member of the ghost Lost Colony of Roanoke | Ambrose White | 21%
|