| Season 1 | Season 2 | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Pablo Emilio Escobar Gaviria | Pablo Emilio Escobar Gaviria | 99%
|
| Javier Peña | Javier Peña | 83%
|
| Steve Murphy | Steve Murphy | 78%
|
| Tata Escobar | César Gaviria | 67%
|
| Gustavo de Jesús Gaviria Rivero | La Quica | 63%
|
| Hélmer "Pacho" Herrera | 63%
| |
| La Quica | Hermilda Gaviria | 55%
|
| Horacio Carrillo | Tata Escobar | 53%
|
| Blackie | Colonel Hugo Martinez | 52%
|
| Limón | 52%
| |
| César Gaviria | Gilberto Rodríguez Orejuela | 47%
|
| Poison | Fernando Duque | 47%
|
| Miguel Rodríguez Orejuela | 44%
| |
| Gilberto Rodríguez Orejuela | 42%
| |
| Jorge Ochoa | El Lion | 42%
|
| Gonzalo Rodríguez Gacha | Horacio Carrillo | 38%
|
| José "Chepe" Santacruz-Londoño | 36%
| |
| Judy Moncada | 36%
| |
| Fabio Ochoa | Limón | 34%
|
| Valeria Vélez | Judy Moncada | 31%
|
| Jorge Salcedo | 25%
| |
| Carlos Castaño Gil | 24%
| |
| Navegante | 24%
| |
| Connie Murphy | Connie Murphy | 23%
|
| Don Berna | 23%
| |
| María Salazar | 23%
| |
| Colonel Hugo Martinez | 22%
| |
| David Rodríguez | 21%
| |
| Hermilda Gaviria | Eduardo Sandoval | 19%
|
| Carlos Lehder | Blackie | 18%
|
| Amado Carrillo Fuentes | 17%
| |
| El Lion | Valeria Vélez | 17%
|
| Fidel Antonio Castaño Gil | 17%
| |
| Fernando Duque | Hélmer "Pacho" Herrera | 16%
|
| Carlos Córdova | 15%
| |
| Velasco | 15%
| |
| Claudio Salazar | 14%
| |
| Eduardo Sandoval | Bill Stechner | 14%
|
| Paola Salcedo | 14%
| |
| Guillermo Pallomari | 12%
| |
| Chris Feistl | 11%
| |
| Bill Stechner | 10%
| |
| Daniel Van Ness | 9%
| |
| Christina Jurado | 8%
| |
| Franklin Jurado | 8%
| |
| Sureshot | Gustavo de Greiff | 5%
|
| Gustavo de Greiff | 3%
|