| Position | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | 1986–2006* | Steve Yzerman | 100%
|
| C | 2021–Present | Dylan Larkin | 98%
|
| RW | 1958–62* | Gordie Howe | 93%
|
| C | 2013–18 | Henrik Zetterberg | 93%
|
| LW | 1941–42* | Syd Howe | 93%
|
| D | 2006–12* | Nicklas Lidström | 87%
|
| LW | 1952–56* | Ted Lindsay | 71%
|
| C | 1962–73* | Alex Delvecchio | 69%
|
| C | 1942–43, 1945–52* | Sid Abel | 51%
|
| D | 1956–58* | Red Kelly | 49%
|
| C | 1974–75* | Marcel Dionne | 33%
|
| RW | 1982–86 | Danny Gare | 31%
|
| RW | 1974 | Mickey Redmond | 31%
|
| C | 1979–80 | Dale McCourt | 24%
|
| D | 1980–82 | Reed Larson | 24%
|
| LW | 1977–78 | Dan Maloney | 20%
|
| LW | 1975–77 | Danny Grant | 20%
|
| RW | 1976–77 | Dennis Polonich | 20%
|
| D | 1973–74 | Gary Bergman | 18%
|
| LW | 1973, 1979 | Nick Libett | 18%
|
| LW | 1978–79 | Dennis Hextall | 13%
|
| D | 1934–35, 1938–41* | Ebbie Goodfellow | 13%
|
| D | 1944–45 | Flash Hollett | 13%
|
| RW | 1932–33 | Larry Aurie | 13%
|
| LW | 1979 | Paul Woods | 13%
|
| C | 1973 | Red Berenson | 13%
|
| D | 1975–76 | Terry Harper | 13%
|
| D | 1935–38 | Doug Young | 11%
|
| LW | 1980–81 | Errol Thompson | 11%
|
| LW | 1933–34* | Herbie Lewis | 11%
|
| RW | 1943–44 | Mud Bruneteau | 11%
|
| RW | 1931–32 | Carson Cooper | 9%
|
| D | 1926–27 | Art Duncan | 7%
|
| LW | 1930–31* | George Hay | 7%
|
| C | 1927–30* | Reg Noble | 7%
|
| D | 1974 | Ted Harris | 7%
|
| D | 1974 | Larry Johnston | 4%
|