| Position | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | 2016–Present | Connor McDavid | 100%
|
| C | 1988–91* | Mark Messier | 96%
|
| C | 1983–88* | Wayne Gretzky | 96%
|
| LW | 2014 | Ryan Smyth | 70%
|
| D | 1991–92* | Kevin Lowe | 54%
|
| D | 2001–07 | Jason Smith | 45%
|
| C | 1999–2001 | Doug Weight | 44%
|
| C | 2010–12 | Shawn Horcoff | 44%
|
| C | 1992–94 | Craig MacTavish | 34%
|
| LW | 2007–10 | Ethan Moreau | 31%
|
| D | 2013–15 | Andrew Ference | 29%
|
| RW | 1995–99 | Kelly Buchberger | 28%
|
| D | 1972–76 | Al Hamilton | 25%
|
| LW | 1995 | Shayne Corson | 22%
|
| D | 1981–83 | Lee Fogolin | 21%
|
| RW | 1980–81 | Blair MacDonald | 18%
|
| C | 1979–80 | Ron Chipperfield | 12%
|
| LW | 1976–77 | Glen Sather | 7%
|
| D | 1977–79 | Paul Shmyr | 4%
|