| Position | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| RW | 1956–60* | Maurice Richard | 100%
|
| C | 1971–75* | Henri Richard | 96%
|
| C | 2022–Present | Nick Suzuki | 96%
|
| C | 1999–2009 | Saku Koivu | 96%
|
| D | 2018–2022 | Shea Weber | 96%
|
| C | 1961–71* | Jean Béliveau | 92%
|
| LW | 2015–18 | Max Pacioretty | 84%
|
| LW | 1981–89* | Bob Gainey | 72%
|
| C | 1989–94* | Guy Carbonneau | 72%
|
| D | 1979–81* | Serge Savard | 68%
|
| RW | 1975–79* | Yvan Cournoyer | 68%
|
| RW | 2010–14 | Brian Gionta | 64%
|
| C | 1994–95 | Kirk Muller | 64%
|
| C | 1996–99 | Vincent Damphousse | 64%
|
| D | 1960–61* | Doug Harvey | 60%
|
| D | 1989–90* | Chris Chelios | 52%
|
| C | 1995–96 | Pierre Turgeon | 48%
|
| LW | 1940–48* | Toe Blake | 48%
|
| G | 1948* | Bill Durnan | 44%
|
| D | 1948–56* | Émile Bouchard | 44%
|
| RW | 1995 | Mike Keane | 44%
|
| C | 1910–11, 1912–13, 1916–22* | Newsy Lalonde | 40%
|
| D | 1909–10, 1911–12* | Jack Laviolette | 36%
|
| D | 1926–32, 1933–36* | Sylvio Mantha | 28%
|
| D | 1936–39* | Babe Siebert | 24%
|
| G | 1932–33* | George Hainsworth | 24%
|
| D | 1922–25* | Sprague Cleghorn | 16%
|
| D | 1925–26 | Billy Coutu | 8%
|
| D | 1939–40 | Walter Buswell | 8%
|
| D | 1915–16 | Howard McNamara | 4%
|
| LW | 1913–15* | Jimmy Gardner | 4%
|