| Position | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | 2007–Present | Sidney Crosby | 100%
|
| C | 1987–94, 1995–97, 2001–06* | Mario Lemieux | 96%
|
| RW | 1998–2001 | Jaromír Jágr | 95%
|
| C | 1995, 1997–98* | Ron Francis | 47%
|
| RW | 1977–78 | Jean Pronovost | 37%
|
| D | 1981–84 | Randy Carlyle | 26%
|
| C | 1984–86 | Mike Bullard | 23%
|
| LW | 1967–68 | Ab McDonald | 19%
|
| C | 1973–77 | Ron Schock | 12%
|
| C | 1986–87 | Terry Ruskowski | 9%
|
| C | 1978–81 | Orest Kindrachuk | 7%
|
| RW | 1987 | Dan Frawley | 5%
|
| C | 1968–69 | Earl Ingarfield | 5%
|