| Season | State | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1: Murder House: Centers on a family that moves into a house haunted by its deceased former occupants in 2011 | California | 92%
|
| Season 5: Hotel: Focuses on the staff and guests of a supernatural hotel in 2015 | California | 66%
|
| Season 4: Freak Show: Centers around one of the few remaining American freak shows in 1952 | Florida | 58%
|
| Season 3: Coven: Follows a coven of witches who face off against those who wish to destroy them in 2013 | Louisiana | 57%
|
| Season 2: Asylum: Follows the stories of the patients and staff of an institution for the criminally insane in 1964 | Massachusetts | 48%
|
| Season 6: Roanoke: Focuses on the paranormal events that take place at an isolated farmhouse in 2016 | North Carolina | 42%
|
| Season 7: Cult: Centers around a cult terrorizing a suburb in the aftermath of the 2016 U.S. election | Michigan | 34%
|