| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| All-time leading passer in Colts history | Peyton Manning | 99%
|
| City which the Colts used to play in | Baltimore | 96%
|
| Quarterback drafted #1 overall in 2012 | Andrew Luck | 95%
|
| Receiver who caught 112 touchdown passes from that quarterback (the most of any quarterback / receiver duo) | Marvin Harrison | 92%
|
| Running back who led the NFL with 1811 yards rushing in 2021 | Jonathan Taylor | 86%
|
| Event held in Indianapolis each year to help teams evaluate potential draft picks | NFL Scouting Combine | 85%
|
| Quarterback from 1956–1972 who won four NFL championships | Johnny Unitas | 83%
|
| Colts quarterback who later won a college championship as head coach of the Michigan Wolverines | Jim Harbaugh | 81%
|
| Home stadium of the Colts | Lucas Oil Stadium | 81%
|
| Receiver who averaged over 1,000 receiving yards per season from 2012–2021 | T. Y. Hilton | 77%
|
| Receiver who caught 67 touchdown passes from the same quarterback | Reggie Wayne | 76%
|
| Running back known as Edge for short | Edgerrin James | 70%
|
| Head coach of the 2006 Super Bowl champions | Tony Dungy | 63%
|
| Safety who was the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 2007 | Bob Sanders | 50%
|