| Island | State | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Kodiak Island | Alaska | 95%
|
| Galveston Island | Texas | 95%
|
| Santa Catalina | California | 90%
|
| Key Largo | Florida | 90%
|
| Nantucket | Massachusetts | 90%
|
| Ellis Island* | New Jersey | 86%
|
| Hilton Head Island | South Carolina | 86%
|
| Mackinac Island | Michigan | 67%
|
| Governors Island | New York | 62%
|
| Ocracoke Island | North Carolina | 62%
|
| Block Island | Rhode Island | 57%
|
| Mercer Island | Washington | 57%
|
| Wizard Island | Oregon | 52%
|
| Saint Simons Island | Georgia | 43%
|
| Mount Desert Island | Maine | 33%
|
| Madeline Island | Wisconsin | 33%
|