| Year | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Los Angeles FC | Carlos Vela | 87%
|
| 2018 | Atlanta United | Josef Martínez | 83%
|
| 2022 | Nashville SC | Hany Mukhtar | 78%
|
| 2009 | Los Angeles Galaxy | Landon Donovan | 70%
|
| 2021 | New England Revolution | Carles Gil | 61%
|
| 2016 | New York City FC | David Villa | 57%
|
| 2014 | Los Angeles Galaxy | Robbie Keane | 52%
|
| 2015 | Toronto FC | Sebastian Giovinco | 52%
|
| 2017 | Portland Timbers | Diego Valeri | 43%
|
| 2020 | Toronto FC | Alejandro Pozuelo | 39%
|
| 1996 | Tampa Bay Mutiny | Carlos Valderrama | 39%
|
| 2012 | San Jose Earthquakes | Chris Wondolowski | 39%
|
| 2002 | Los Angeles Galaxy | Carlos Ruíz | 30%
|
| 2013 | Chicago Fire | Mike Magee | 30%
|
| 2011 | D.C. United | Dwayne De Rosario | 26%
|
| 1997 | Kansas City Wizards | Preki | 26%
|
| 2003 | Kansas City Wizards | Preki | 26%
|
| 2010 | FC Dallas | David Ferreira | 22%
|
| 1998 | D.C. United | Marco Etcheverry | 22%
|
| 2005 | New England Revolution | Taylor Twellman | 22%
|
| 2000 | Kansas City Wizards | Tony Meola | 22%
|
| 2006 | D.C. United | Christian Gómez | 17%
|
| 1999 | Dallas Burn | Jason Kreis | 17%
|
| 2007 | D.C. United | Luciano Emilio | 17%
|
| 2001 | Miami Fusion | Alex Pineda Chacón | 13%
|
| 2004 | MetroStars | Amado Guevara | 13%
|
| 2008 | Columbus Crew | Guillermo Barros Schelotto | 13%
|