| Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Main Antagonist, second-in-command of the gang | Judge Holden | 100%
|
| Protagonist | The Kid | 94%
|
| Leader of the Gang | John Joel Glanton | 89%
|
| Ex-preist in the gang | Ben Tobin | 56%
|
| Outlaw who brawls with the protagonist at the beginning of the book | Louis Toadvine | 56%
|
| Black outlaw who shares his name with another outlaw | Black Jackson | 44%
|
| White outlaw who shares his name with another outlaw | White Jackson | 44%
|
| Outlaw who deserts the gang after escaping jail | David Brown | 33%
|
| Group of Native Americans in the gang | The Delawares | 33%
|
| Mentally disabled man kept in a cage by his brother | The Idiot | 33%
|
| Leader of the Fillibusters | Captain White | 28%
|
| Outlaw who wears a necklace of ears | Bathcat | 22%
|
| Woman who frees the caged man | Sarah Borginnis | 17%
|
| FIllibuster who survives the Commanche attack and travels with the protagonist | Sproule | 17%
|
| The brother mentioned above | Cloyce Bell | 11%
|
| Outlaw who is supposed to be killed by the protagonist, but is instead left behind | Dick Shelby | 11%
|
| Outlaw who takes an arrow to the leg | Doc Irving | 11%
|
| Mexican General who's forces attack the gang | General Elias | 11%
|
| The preacher seen at the beginning of the novel | Reverend Green | 11%
|
| Governor of Chihuahua City | Angel Trias | 6%
|
| Outlaw, everybody mispronounces his name | Juan “McGill” Miguel | 6%
|
| Scout for the gang, asks the Judge about his sketches | Marcus “Long” Webster | 6%
|
| Prisoner the protagonist meets while jailed in Chihuahua | Grannyrat Chambers | 0%
|