| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Wife of Protagonist | Abigail Marston | 97%
|
| Leader of Gang at Fort Mercer | Bill Williamson | 97%
|
| Head rancher at Macfarlanes Ranch | Bonnie MacFarlane | 92%
|
| Protagonist | John Marston | 92%
|
| Son of protagonist | Jack Marston | 89%
|
| Outlaw hiding in Mexico | Javier Escuella | 86%
|
| Major Bureau of Investigation Agent | Edgar Ross | 75%
|
| Prominant outlaw hiding in Cochinay | Dutch Van Der Linde | 72%
|
| Treasure obbsessed grave-robber | Seth Briars | 69%
|
| The drunkard, named after his country of orgin | Irish | 67%
|
| Leader of Mexican freedom movement | Abraham Reyes | 64%
|
| Old man residing at Beechers Hope | Uncle | 61%
|
| Mexican Army Captain | Vincente de Santa | 61%
|
| Conman who peddles snake oil | Nigel West Dickens | 58%
|
| Old West outlaw retired in Mexico | Landon Ricketts | 56%
|
| Dictatorial Governer of Nuevo Pariso | Agustin Allende | 50%
|
| Marshall of Armadillo | Leigh Johnson | 50%
|
| Female Freedom fighter | Luisa Fortuna | 39%
|
| Racist General Store Owner | Herbert Moon | 33%
|
| Native American, affiliated with the Yale Professor | Nastas | 33%
|
| Bureau of Investigation Agent | Archer Fordham | 31%
|
| MacFarlane patriarch | Drew Macfarlane | 31%
|
| The other Young Armadillo Deputy | Jonah | 31%
|
| Second-in-command outlaw from Fort Mercer | Norman Deek | 22%
|
| Ranch hand at the Macfarlane Ranch | Amos | 19%
|
| Young Armadillo Deputy | Eli | 19%
|
| Stuttering smuggler who is saved in Thieves Landing | Shaky | 19%
|
| Morphine-addicted Yale Professor | Harold MacDougal | 17%
|
| Leader of gang prominant in Cholla Springs | Walton Lowe | 11%
|
| Overweight Mexican Army Captain | Espinosia | 3%
|
| Prominant freedom fighter, bald. | Victor Malendez | 3%
|