| Description | Movie | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Unsupervised child uses booby traps to defeat burglars | Home Alone | 99%
|
| Man, raised as an elf, goes to New York City | Elf | 96%
|
| Green curmudgeon commits attempted burglary in Whoville | How the Grinch Stole Christmas | 88%
|
| A magical train takes a conductor, children, and a hobo to the north pole | The Polar Express | 80%
|
| A miser finds redemption after being visited by three Christmas spirits | A Christmas Carol | 74%
|
| If Santa falls off your roof and dies, YOU become Santa | The Santa Clause | 65%
|
| A guy kills terrorists in a Los Angeles skyscraper. Also, its Christmas | Die Hard | 64%
|
| The citizens of Halloween Town take over Christmas town | The Nightmare Before Christmas | 64%
|
| The perfect Christmas present – just don't get it wet or feed it after midnight! | Gremlins | 59%
|
| Kid will shoot his eye out if he gets a BB gun for Christmas | A Christmas Story | 55%
|
| Clark Griswold's plan for a perfect Christmas go predictably awry | National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation | 50%
|
| Mall santa and elf rob a different mall every Christmas | Bad Santa | 49%
|
| Macy's department store Santa just might be the real Santa | Miracle on 34th Street | 49%
|
| Suicidal man, rescued by an angel, is shown what things would be like if he never lived | It's a Wonderful Life | 48%
|
| Deceased dad gets a second chance to be a doting father... as a snowman | Jack Frost | 44%
|
| Modern take on the above, with Bill Murray as a cold-hearted TV exec | Scrooged | 41%
|
| Musclebound father goes to great lengths to obtain a sold-out toy | Jingle All the Way | 37%
|
| Suburban couple skips Christmas for a Caribbean cruise | Christmas With the Kranks | 28%
|