| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Durin's Bane (Balrog at Moria) | Gandalf the Gray | 89%
|
| Déagol | Sméagol | 85%
|
| Smaug | Bard the Bowman | 83%
|
| Witch-King of Angmar | Éowyn | 78%
|
| Saruman | Gríma Wormtongue | 74%
|
| Sauron (spirit) | Frodo - Gollum - Eru Ilúvatar | 70%
|
| Azog | Thorin II | 68%
|
| Denethor II | Denethor II | 65%
|
| Thrór I | Azog | 59%
|
| Fili | Azog | 59%
|
| Kili | Bolg | 51%
|
| Sauron (prologue) | Gil-Galad - Elendil | 45%
|
| Bolg | Legolas | 42%
|
| Fingolfin | Morgoth | 31%
|
| Glaurung | Túrin | 30%
|
| Finrod | Sauron | 27%
|
| Háma | Warg | 22%
|
| Ancalagon the Black | Eärendil | 20%
|
| Oín | Watcher in the water | 18%
|
| Beren | Carcharoth | 16%
|
| Adar | Glûg | 3%
|