| Character | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Carol Burnett, Liz's TGS-loving pilot boyfriend | Matt Damon | 94%
|
| Drew Baird, handsome and dimwitted doctor | Jon Hamm | 90%
|
| Claire, Liz and Jenna's crazy college roommate | Jennifer Aniston | 84%
|
| Gavin Volure, agoraphobic and reclusive millionaire | Steve Martin | 84%
|
| Nancy Donovan, Jack's childhood crush with a heavy Boston accent | Julianne Moore | 81%
|
| Lenny Wosniak, private investigator | Steve Buscemi | 74%
|
| Avery Jessup, CNBC reporter and Jack's second wife | Elizabeth Banks | 68%
|
| Stewart LaGrange, UN employee that Liz mistakes for a little boy | Peter Dinklage | 68%
|
| Regina Bookman, democratic congresswoman | Queen Latifah | 61%
|
| Cooter Burger, member of the Bush administration | Matthew Broderick | 55%
|
| Raheem, Liz's neighbor whom she believes is a terrorist | Fred Armisen | 52%
|
| Lynn Onkman, Frank's middle school teacher and lover | Susan Sarandon | 52%
|
| Tom, NBC maintenance man who discovers a gas leak in the sixth floor in his final day before retirement | Michael Keaton | 45%
|
| Bianca, Jack's first wife | Isabella Rossellini | 42%
|
| Ron, Kenneth's hillbilly step-father | Bryan Cranston | 35%
|
| Ritchie, NBC editor and Civil War re-enactor | Paul Giamatti | 35%
|
| Kim Jong-Il / Kim Jong-Un | Margaret Cho | 26%
|
| Sylvia Rossitano, Frank's mother | Patti LuPone | 26%
|
| Mitch, Liz's amnesiac younger brother stuck in 1985 | Andy Richter | 23%
|
| Colleen Donaghy, Jack's mother | Elaine Stritch | 23%
|