| Death | Person | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Shot three times by Lurtz and died of wounds | Boromir | 98%
|
| Falls into lava | Gollum | 88%
|
| Stabbed by Wormtongue then impaled on a spike | Saruman | 82%
|
| Killed after the ring was destroyed | Sauron | 81%
|
| Thrown by fellbeast then crushed by horse | Théoden | 76%
|
| Stabbed by Merry, then stabbed by Éowyn | Witch King of Angmar | 74%
|
| Strangled by Sméagol | Déagol | 72%
|
| Gets set on fire, then jumps off a tower | Denethor | 72%
|
| Decapitated by Aragorn | Lurtz | 71%
|
| Shot to death by orcs | Isildur | 69%
|
| Stabbed by Gandalf and fell onto mountainside | Durin's Bane | 68%
|
| Killed by Sauron | Elendil | 58%
|
| Shot by Legolas | Grima Wormtongue | 56%
|
| Killer by Éomer | Uglúk | 56%
|
| Decapitated by Aragorn | The Mouth of Sauron | 52%
|
| Stabbed by Gimli, then stabbed by Aragorn | Gothmog | 49%
|
| Wounded by orcs then poisoned by Wormtongue | Théodred | 49%
|
| Killed by Sauron | Gil-galad | 41%
|
| Killed by warg rider, then eaten by warg | Háma | 41%
|
| Stabbed twice by an uruk | Haldir | 40%
|
| Crushed by Treebeard | Grishnákh | 27%
|
| Decapitated by Uglúk then eaten by orcs | Snaga | 21%
|
| Killed by Sam | Gorbag | 19%
|
| Injured by an orc, then killed by Gothmog | Madril | 12%
|
| Killed by the eruption of Mount Doom | Khamûl and the Ringwraiths | 9%
|
| Killed by Gimli | Guritz | 3%
|