| % | Hint | President | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 44% | His native language was Dutch | Martin Van Buren | 80%
|
| 42% | Disparagingly known as "his accidency", he became President after the death of William Henry Harrison | John Tyler | 74%
|
| 41% | President during the Spanish-American War, assassinated in 1901 | William McKinley | 73%
|
| 41% | Hero of the Mexican-American war, he died 16 months into his term | Zachary Taylor | 73%
|
| 40% | Considered one of the worst Presidents for failing to prevent the Civil War | James Buchanan | 71%
|
| 35% | Became President after the assassination of Garfield | Chester A. Arthur | 67%
|
| 36% | The last Whig President | Millard Fillmore | 65%
|
| 36% | Signed the Kansas-Nebraska Act which created "Bleeding Kansas" | Franklin Pierce | 61%
|
| 35% | Awarded the Presidency by a Congressional commission after a disputed election | Rutherford B. Hayes | 60%
|
| 37% | Nominated in a "smoke-filled room", he is known for the Teapot Dome scandal | Warren Harding | 60%
|