| Rank | Team(s) | Years | Primary Position | WAR | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | BOS, NYY, BSN | 1914-1935 | OF/LHP | 182.6 | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| 4. | PIT, SFG | 1986-2007 | OF | 162.8 | Barry Bonds | 100%
|
| 218. | SFG, NYY, CAL, CHW, TEX, CLE, STL, CHC | 1968-1981 | OF | 57.9 | Bobby Bonds | 100%
|
| BOS, NYY, CIN, NYG | 1915-1929 | RHP | 51.3 | Carl Mays | 100%
| |
| 180. | BRA, HAR, BSN, WOR, BOS, IND | 1874-1882; 1884 | RHP | 60.9 | Tommy Bond | 100%
|
| 5. | NYG, SFG, NYM | 1954-1973 | OF | 156.1 | Willie Mays | 100%
|
| 29. | STL, LAA, LAD, STL | 2001-2022 | 1B | 101.2 | Albert Pujols | 97%
|
| 16. | SEA, TEX, NYY | 1994-2013; 2015-2016 | 3B | 117.4 | Alex Rodriguez | 97%
|
| 165. | ATL, LAD, TEX, CHW, NYY | 1996-2012 | OF | 62.7 | Andruw Jones | 97%
|
| CHC, OAK | 1959-1976 | OF | 63.6 | Billy Williams | 97%
| |
| 242. | PHA, WSH, BOS | 1933-1945 | OF | 55.7 | Bob Johnson | 97%
|
| BAL | 1981-2001 | SS | 95.9 | Cal Ripken Jr. | 97%
| |
| 52. | ATL | 1993; 1995-2012 | 3B | 85.3 | Chipper Jones | 97%
|
| 3. | CLV, STL, BOS, CLE, BSN | 1890-1911 | RHP | 163.6 | Cy Young | 97%
|
| 28. | CHC, ATL, CHC, LAD, SDP, LAD | 1986-2008 | RHP | 106.6 | Greg Maddux | 97%
|
| TEX, FLA, DET, NYY, HOU, TEX, WSN | 1991-2011 | C | 68.7 | Ivan Rodriguez | 97%
| |
| 21. | NYY | 1951-1968 | OF | 110.2 | Mickey Mantle | 97%
|
| PHI | 1972-1989 | 3B | 106.9 | Mike Schmidt | 97%
| |
| 30. | MON, SEA, HOU, ARI, NYY, ARI, SFG | 1988-2009 | LHP | 101.1 | Randy Johnson | 97%
|
| 8. | BOS, TOR, NYY, HOU, NYY | 1984-2007 | RHP | 139.2 | Roger Clemens | 97%
|
| 14. | BOS | 1939-1942; 1946-1960 | OF | 121.8 | Ted Williams | 97%
|
| CLE, CHW, LAD, NYY, CAL, OAK, NYY | 1963-1974; 1976-1989 | LHP | 61.6 | Tommy John | 97%
| |
| 2. | WSH | 1907-1927 | RHP | 167.8 | Walter Johnson | 97%
|
| 47. | STL | 1959-1975 | RHP | 89.1 | Bob Gibson | 93%
|
| 71. | BAL | 1955-1977 | 3B | 78.3 | Brooks Robinson | 93%
|
| 33. | BOS | 1961-1983 | OF | 96.5 | Carl Yastrzemski | 93%
|
| 96. | NYY | 1995-2014 | SS | 71.3 | Derek Jeter | 93%
|
| SEA | 1987-2004 | DH | 68.4 | Edgar Martinez | 93%
| |
| 23. | CIN, BAL, LAD, CAL, CLE | 1956-1976 | 3B | 107.3 | Frank Robinson | 93%
|
| 48. | KCR | 1973-1993 | 3B | 88.6 | George Brett | 93%
|
| 7. | MLN, ATL, MIL | 1954-1976 | OF | 143.2 | Henry Aaron | 93%
|
| 151. | BRO | 1947-1956 | 2B | 63.9 | Jackie Robinson | 93%
|
| 31. | HOU, CIN, HOU, SFG, PHI, OAK | 1963-1984 | 2B | 100.6 | Joe Morgan | 93%
|
| 84. | CIN | 1967-1983 | C | 75.1 | Johnny Bench | 93%
|
| 58. | SEA, CIN, CHW, SEA | 1989-2010 | OF | 83.8 | Ken Griffey Jr. | 93%
|
| 18. | NYY | 1923-1939 | 1B | 113.7 | Lou Gehrig | 93%
|
| 51. | LAA | 2011-present | OF | 86.1 | Mike Trout | 93%
|
| 61. | NYM, CAL, HOU, TEX | 1966; 1968-1993 | RHP | 81.3 | Nolan Ryan | 93%
|
| 76. | SDP, STL | 1978-1996 | SS | 76.9 | Ozzie Smith | 93%
|
| 144. | BOS, STL, LAD, SFG | 1966-1982 | OF | 64.6 | Reggie Smith | 93%
|
| 19. | OAK, NYY, OAK, TOR, OAK, SDP, ANA, OAK, NYM, SEA, SDP, BOS, LAD | 1979-2003 | OF | 111.2 | Rickey Henderson | 93%
|
| 37. | PIT | 1955-1972 | OF | 94.9 | Roberto Clemente | 93%
|
| PHI, STL, TOR, CIN | 1996-2012 | 3B | 70.1 | Scott Rolen | 93%
| |
| 11. | STL | 1941-1944; 1946-1963 | OF | 128.6 | Stan Musial | 93%
|
| 6. | DET, PHA | 1905-1928 | OF | 151.4 | Ty Cobb | 93%
|
| 40. | LAD, SEA, BOS, TEX | 1998-2018 | 3B | 93.7 | Adrian Beltre | 90%
|
| 68. | LAD | 2008-present | LHP | 79.2 | Clayton Kershaw | 90%
|
| 141. | HOU | 1988-2007 | 2B | 65.4 | Craig Biggio | 90%
|
| 34. | BSN, MLN, ATL, HOU, DET | 1952-1968 | 1B | 96.0 | Eddie Mathews | 90%
|
| 88. | CHW, OAK, TOR, OAK | 1990-2008 | DH | 73.8 | Frank Thomas | 90%
|
| 65. | HOU | 1991-2005 | 1B | 79.9 | Jeff Bagwell | 90%
|
| 90. | CLE, PHI, CHW, LAD, MIN, CLE, PHI, BAL | 1991-2012 | 1B | 73.1 | Jim Thome | 90%
|
| 170. | PHA, CLE, CHW | 1908-1920 | OF | 62.2 | Joe Jackson | 90%
|
| 64. | DET, HOU, NYM, HOU, SFG | 2005-2020; 2022-present | RHP | 80.5 | Justin Verlander | 90%
|
| STL, CHC, PHI | 1955-1968 | RHP | 52.0 | Larry Jackson | 90%
| |
| 92. | MON, COL, STL | 1989-2005 | OF | 72.7 | Larry Walker | 90%
|
| 128. | FLA, DET | 2003-2023 | 3B | 67.2 | Miguel Cabrera | 90%
|
| 91. | BOS, LAD | 2014-present | OF | 72.9 | Mookie Betts | 90%
|
| 57. | LAD, MON, BOS, NYM, PHI | 1992-2009 | RHP | 83.9 | Pedro Martinez | 90%
|
| 66. | CIN, PHI, MON, CIN | 1963-1986 | OF | 79.6 | Pete Rose | 90%
|
| 87. | KCA, OAK, BAL, NYY, CAL, OAK | 1967-1987 | OF | 74.0 | Reggie Jackson | 90%
|
| 63. | ATL, NYM, ATL | 1987-2008 | LHP | 80.7 | Tom Glavine | 90%
|
| 22. | NYM, CIN, NYM CHW, BOS | 1967-1986 | RHP | 109.9 | Tom Seaver | 90%
|
| 73. | KCR, MIL, LAA, LAD, ARI, HOU, KCR | 2004-2023 | RHP | 77.4 | Zack Greinke | 90%
|
| 105. | KCR, HOU, NYM, SFG, STL, NYY, TEX, HOU | 1998-2017 | OF | 70.0 | Carlos Beltran | 86%
|
| 27. | NYG, CIN | 1900-1916 | RHP | 106.7 | Christy Mathewson | 86%
|
| 67. | BAL, HOU, PHI, ARI, BOS | 1988-2007 | RHP | 79.5 | Curt Schilling | 86%
|
| 127. | CHC | 1953-1971 | SS | 67.7 | Ernie Banks | 86%
|
| 103. | MON, NYM, SFG, LAD, MON | 1974-1992 | C | 70.1 | Gary Carter | 86%
|
| 10. | LOU, PIT | 1897-1917 | SS | 131.0 | Honus Wagner | 86%
|
| 41. | PHA, BOS, CHC, PHI | 1925-1942; 1944-1945 | 1B | 92.9 | Jimmie Foxx | 86%
|
| 111. | ATL, BOS, STL | 1988-1999; 2001-2009 | RHP | 69.0 | John Smoltz | 86%
|
| 257. | CLE | 2013-present | 3B | 54.8 | Jose Ramirez | 86%
|
| 109. | CLE, BOS, LAD, CHW, TBR | 1993-2011 | OF | 69.3 | Manny Ramirez | 86%
|
| 60. | BAL, NYY | 1991-2008 | RHP | 82.8 | Mike Mussina | 86%
|
| MIL | 1974-1993 | SS | 77.4 | Robin Yount | 86%
| |
| 174. | COL | 1997-2013 | 1B | 61.8 | Todd Helton | 86%
|
| 110. | SDP | 1982-2001 | OF | 69.1 | Tony Gwynn | 86%
|
| 43. | BOS, NYY, TBD | 1982-1999 | 3B | 91.4 | Wade Boggs | 86%
|
| 42. | DET | 1953-1974 | OF | 92.7 | Al Kaline | 83%
|
| 100. | CIN | 1986-2004 | SS | 70.5 | Barry Larkin | 83%
|
| 251. | KEK, BAL, NYU, CIN, PRO, BSN, PHA | 1871-1877; 1879; 1881-1887 | RHP | 55.4 | Bobby Mathews | 83%
|
| WSH, PHI | 2012-present | OF | 52.4 | Bryce Harper | 83%
| |
| 119. | BOS, CHW | 1969; 1971-1993 | C | 68.4 | Carlton Fisk | 83%
|
| 255. | MIN, BOS | 1997-2016 | DH | 55.0 | David Ortiz | 83%
|
| 69. | NYY | 1936-1942; 1946-1951 | OF | 79.1 | Joe DiMaggio | 83%
|
| NYY | 1995-2013 | RHP | 56.3 | Mariano Rivera | 83%
| |
| ARI, DET, WSN, LAD, NYM, TEX, TOR | 2008-present | RHP | 75.3 | Max Scherzer | 83%
| |
| LAD, FLA, NYM, SDP, OAK | 1992-2007 | C | 59.5 | Mike Piazza | 83%
| |
| 95. | CHC, TEX, BAL, TEX, BAL | 1986-2005 | 1B | 71.9 | Rafael Palmeiro | 83%
|
| 131. | SDP, TOR, BAL, CLE, NYM, CHW, ARI, CHW | 1988-2004 | 2B | 67.0 | Roberto Alomar | 83%
|
| 62. | MIN, CAL | 1967-1985 | 2B | 81.2 | Rod Carew | 83%
|
| 148. | TOR, PHI | 1998-2013 | RHP | 64.2 | Roy Halladay | 83%
|
| 9. | BOS, CLE, WSH, PHA | 1907-1928 | OF | 134.9 | Tris Speaker | 83%
|
| 146. | SFG, SDP, OAK, SFG | 1959-1980 | 1B | 64.5 | Willie McCovey | 83%
|
| PIT | 1962-1982 | LF | 57.6 | Willie Stargell | 83%
| |
| 215. | NYY | 2016-present | OF | 58.1 | Aaron Judge | 79%
|
| SDP, NYY, CAL, TOR, MIN, CLE | 1973-1988; 1990-1995 | OF | 64.2 | Dave Winfield | 79%
| |
| 195. | SEA, NYY, MIA, SEA | 2001-2019 | OF | 60.0 | Ichiro Suzuki | 79%
|
| BAL | 1965-1967; 1969-1984 | RHP | 68.5 | Jim Palmer | 79%
| |
| OAK, STL | 1986-2001 | 1B | 62.2 | Mark McGwire | 79%
| |
| 24. | PHI, CLE, PHA | 1896-1916 | 2B | 106.9 | Nap Lajoie | 79%
|
| 197. | NYY, NYM | 1946-1963; 1965 | C | 59.5 | Yogi Berra | 79%
|
| NYY, HOU, NYY | 1995-2010; 2012-2013 | LHP | 60.2 | Andy Pettitte | 76%
| |
| 156. | CLE | 1936-1941; 1945-1956 | RHP | 63.4 | Bob Feller | 76%
|
| 135. | CLE, TEX, CIN, HOU, TEX | 1972-1989 | 3B | 66.3 | Buddy Bell | 76%
|
| CLE, MIL, NYY | 2001-2019 | LHP | 62.3 | CC Sabathia | 76%
| |
| PHI, LAD | 2003-2018 | 2B | 64.6 | Chase Utley | 76%
| |
| 208. | TBR, SFG, ARI | 2008-2023 | 3B | 58.9 | Evan Longoria | 76%
|
| ATL, LAD | 2010-present | 1B | 63.1 | Freddie Freeman | 76%
| |
| WSH, MIN, KCR | 1954-1975 | 1B | 60.4 | Harmon Killebrew | 76%
| |
| HOU, CHC, HOU, DET, ARI, LAD, FLA | 1990-2008 | OF | 51.6 | Luis Gonzalez | 76%
| |
| 20. | NYG | 1926-1947 | OF | 111.0 | Mel Ott | 76%
|
| 112. | NYY, SEA, NYM, SDP, ATL | 2005-2020; 2022 | 2B | 68.7 | Robinson Cano | 76%
|
| 12. | STL, NYG, BSN, CHC, STL, SLB | 1915-1937 | 2B | 127.1 | Rogers Hornsby | 76%
|
| TEX, CHW, CHC, BAL, TEX | 1989-2005; 2007 | OF | 58.6 | Sammy Sosa | 76%
| |
| 264. | CIN, MON, BOS, PHI, CIN | 1964-1986 | 1B | 53.9 | Tony Perez | 76%
|
| MON, ANA, LAA, TEX, BAL | 1996-2011 | OF | 59.5 | Vladimir Guerrero | 76%
| |
| 228. | NYY | 1950; 1953-1967 | LHP | 57.0 | Whitey Ford | 76%
|
| 39. | ROK, ATH, CHC | 1871-1897 | 1B | 94.3 | Cap Anson | 72%
|
| BAL, LAD, NYM, CLE, BAL, ANA, LAD | 1977-1997 | 1B | 68.7 | Eddie Murray | 72%
| |
| 184. | MIL, SDP, FLA, LAD, ATL, NYY, DET, NYM | 1988-2009 | OF | 60.5 | Gary Sheffield | 72%
|
| 54. | CLV, NYG, CHW, NYG, CHW | 1890-1909 | SS | 84.5 | George Davis | 72%
|
| 294. | MIN, NYM | 2000-2010; 2012 | LHP | 51.7 | Johan Santana | 72%
|
| 126. | TEX, BAL, FLA, SDP, LAD, NYY | 1986; 1988-2005 | RHP | 67.8 | Kevin Brown | 72%
|
| MIN | 1984-1995 | OF | 51.1 | Kirby Puckett | 72%
| |
| 217. | STL, CHC, SLM, BTT, CHI, CHC | 1903-1916 | RHP | 58.0 | Mordecai Brown | 72%
|
| 225. | COL, STL | 2013-present | 3B | 57.3 | Nolan Arenado | 72%
|
| 150. | ARI, STL, NYY | 2011-present | 1B | 64.1 | Paul Goldschmidt | 72%
|
| 79. | MIL, TOR, MIN | 1978-1998 | DH | 75.7 | Paul Molitor | 72%
|
| 35. | MLN, ATL, NYY, CLE, TOR, ATL | 1964-1987 | RHP | 95.9 | Phil Niekro | 72%
|
| 50. | PHI, BAL, HOU, CHC | 1948-1966 | RHP | 86.2 | Robin Roberts | 72%
|
| 45. | STL, PHI, SFG, CHW, CLE, MIN | 1965-1988 | LHP | 90.2 | Steve Carlton | 72%
|
| MIN, LAA, DET, MIN | 1997-2015 | OF | 50.6 | Torii Hunter | 72%
| |
| 32. | BSN, MLN, NYM, SFG | 1942; 1946-1965 | LHP | 100.1 | Warren Spahn | 72%
|
| 182. | LAD, MON, TEX, STL, SDP, CAL | 1960-1976; 1979 | OF | 60.8 | Willie Davis | 72%
|
| MON, CHC, BOS, FLA | 1976-1996 | OF | 64.8 | Andre Dawson | 69%
| |
| 172. | CLE, BOS, CHC, OAK, STL, BOS | 1975-1998 | RHP | 62.1 | Dennis Eckersley | 69%
|
| 56. | PHI, CHC, TEX, BOS, CHC | 1965-1983 | RHP | 84.1 | Fergie Jenkins | 69%
|
| 15. | PHI, CHC, STL, PHI | 1911-1930 | SP | 119.7 | Grover Alexander | 69%
|
| DET, PIT | 1930; 1933-1941; 1945-1947 | 1B | 55.6 | Hank Greenberg | 69%
| |
| 154. | CIN | 2007-2023 | 1B | 63.6 | Joey Votto | 69%
|
| SFG, BOS, LAD | 1960-1975 | RHP | 62.8 | Juan Marichal | 69%
| |
| 190. | STL, NYM, CLE | 1974-1990 | 1B | 60.3 | Keith Hernandez | 69%
|
| PHI, CHC | 1981-1994; 1996-1997 | 2B | 67.9 | Ryne Sandberg | 69%
| |
| WSH, CLE | 1915-1934 | OF | 54.4 | Sam Rice | 69%
| |
| 99. | DET | 1977-1996 | SS | 70.6 | Alan Trammell | 66%
|
| 38. | MIN, TEX, PIT, CLE, MIN, CAL | 1970-1990; 1992 | RHP | 94.5 | Bert Blyleven | 66%
|
| 157. | KCC, PHI, BSN | 1888-1901 | OF | 63.2 | Billy Hamilton | 66%
|
| 254. | CHW, BOS, ATL | 2010-2019; 2021-present | LHP | 55.1 | Chris Sale | 66%
|
| 166. | KCR, NYM, TOR, KCR, TOR, NYY, BOS, NYM | 1986-2001; 2003 | RHP | 62.3 | David Cone | 66%
|
| 308. | OAK, NYY, OAK, COL, CLE | 1995-2014 | 1B | 50.5 | Jason Giambi | 66%
|
| MIN | 2004-2018 | C | 55.6 | Joe Mauer | 66%
| |
| 292. | HOU, NYY, STL, TEX | 1999-2013 | OF | 51.9 | Lance Berkman | 66%
|
| 26. | PHA, BOS | 1925-1941 | SP | 106.8 | Lefty Grove | 66%
|
| TEX, ATL, LAA, NYY | 2003-2016 | 1B | 50.5 | Mark Teixeira | 66%
| |
| PHI, TEX, CHC, ATL | 2006-2020 | LHP | 59.0 | Cole Hamels | 62%
| |
| BRO, LAD, NYM, SFG | 1947-1964 | OF | 65.9 | Duke Snider | 62%
| |
| BOS | 2006-2019 | 2B | 51.9 | Dustin Pedroia | 62%
| |
| 13. | PHA, CHW, PHA | 1906-1930 | 2B | 124.3 | Eddie Collins | 62%
|
| 273. | BSN, LOU, BSN, BOS, PHA | 1895-1908 | 3B | 53.3 | Jimmy Collins | 62%
|
| 285. | HOU | 2011-present | 2B | 52.4 | Jose Altuve | 62%
|
| HOU, CLE, ATL, CLE, CHW, SFG, PIT, CHC, NYY, PHI, LAD, TEX, CLE | 1991-2007 | OF | 68.4 | Kenny Lofton | 62%
| |
| BRO, LAD | 1940-1942; 1946-1958 | SS | 68.4 | Pee Wee Reese | 62%
| |
| 319. | HOU, PHI, TEX, COL | 2001-2013 | RHP | 50.0 | Roy Oswalt | 62%
|
| 108. | MON, CHW, NYY, OAK, MON, BAL, FLA | 1979-1999; 2001-2002 | OF | 69.4 | Tim Raines | 62%
|
| 72. | PIT, BRO | 1932-1943; 1947-1948 | SS | 77.9 | Arky Vaughan | 59%
|
| 132. | LAD, HOU, MIL, OAK, CAL, LAD | 1966-1988 | RHP | 66.7 | Don Sutton | 59%
|
| NYM, NYY, CLE, HOU, TBD, NYY | 1984-1994; 1996-2000 | RHP | 53.0 | Dwight Gooden | 59%
| |
| TOR, SDP, ATL, TBD, CHC, LAD, TBD | 1986-2004 | 1B | 52.6 | Fred McGriff | 59%
| |
| 46. | SFG, CLE, TEX, SDP, TEX, NYY, ATL, SEA, KCR | 1962-1983 | RHP | 90.0 | Gaylord Perry | 59%
|
| 241. | CHW, BAL, CHW, BOS | 1956-1973 | SS | 55.8 | Luis Aparicio | 59%
|
| BAL, LAD, SDP | 2012-2025 | 3B | 60.4 | Manny Machado | 59%
| |
| KCR, NYM, COL, BOS | 1984-1996; 1997-1999; 2001 | RHP | 58.9 | Bret Saberhagen | 55%
| |
| 53. | DET | 1924-1942 | 2B | 84.8 | Charlie Gehringer | 55%
|
| ATL, SFG, DET, ATL | 1969-1989 | 3B | 58.7 | Darrell Evans | 55%
| |
| TOR, DET, CIN, BAL, NYY, TOR, CHW, NYY, SDP, BOS, SDP, LAD | 1987-2007 | LHP | 53.4 | David Wells | 55%
| |
| BOS, BAL | 1972-1991 | OF | 67.2 | Dwight Evans | 55%
| |
| 288. | CLE, NYM | 2015-present | SS | 52.3 | Francisco Lindor | 55%
|
| 123. | LOU, PIT | 1894-1911; 1913-1915 | OF | 68.0 | Fred Clarke | 55%
|
| 276. | SFG, STL, NYY, SDP, BOS | 1975-1992 | OF | 53.1 | Jack Clark | 55%
|
| TOR, NYM, CLE, SFG, HOU, LAD | 1992-2008 | 2B | 55.5 | Jeff Kent | 55%
| |
| 234. | KCR, OAK, BOS, NYY, DET, TBR, CLE | 1995-2012 | OF | 56.3 | Johnny Damon | 55%
|
| 80. | CIN, DET | 1899-1917 | OF | 75.4 | Sam Crawford | 55%
|
| 230. | SFG, TEX, BAL, STL | 1986-2000 | 1B | 56.5 | Will Clark | 55%
|
| PHA, CHW, DET, WSH, BSN, CIN, PHA, BOS, PHA | 1924-1941; 1943-1944 | OF | 68.5 | Al Simmons | 52%
| |
| 232. | NYY | 1928-1943; 1946 | C | 56.4 | Bill Dickey | 52%
|
| 191. | HOU, PHI, NYY, LAA, LAD, NYM | 1996-2012; 2014 | OF | 60.2 | Bobby Abreu | 52%
|
| 210. | PHI, STL, LAD, CHW, PHI, OAK | 1963-1977 | 1B | 58.7 | Dick Allen | 52%
|
| 316. | BOS, CAL, BAL, DET, SDP | 1974-1990 | OF | 50.2 | Fred Lynn | 52%
|
| 185. | CAL, ANA, STL, SDP, CHC, MIL, CIN | 1993-2008; 2010 | OF | 60.4 | Jim Edmonds | 52%
|
| MLN, ATL, STL, NYM | 1960-1977 | C | 57.6 | Joe Torre | 52%
| |
| DET | 1977-1995 | 2B | 75.1 | Lou Whitaker | 52%
| |
| 75. | CHW | 1930-1943; 1945-1950 | SS | 77.2 | Luke Appling | 52%
|
| 317. | SFG, STL, ATL, OAK, BOS, KCR | 1958-1974 | 1B | 50.1 | Orlando Cepeda | 52%
|
| STL, MIL, ATL | 1968-1988 | C | 50.4 | Ted Simmons | 52%
| |
| OAK, ATL, SFG | 1999-2015 | RHP | 57.9 | Tim Hudson | 52%
| |
| 44. | PHA, SLM, SLB | 1901-1917 | LHP | 91.2 | Eddie Plank | 48%
|
| 124. | MIN, CLE, NYY, SDP, ATL, MON | 1967-1988 | 3B | 67.9 | Graig Nettles | 48%
|
| 260. | STL, HOU, NYY | 1970-1988 | OF | 54.4 | Jose Cruz | 48%
|
| TEX, NYY, OAK, NYM, TEX, MIN, TEX, DET | 1989-2008 | LHP | 50.5 | Kenny Rogers | 48%
| |
| 203. | CHW, MIA, TOR | 2000-2015 | LHP | 59.0 | Mark Buehrle | 48%
|
| 86. | PIT, BRO, BSN, BRO, NYY | 1926-1945 | OF | 74.7 | Paul Waner | 48%
|
| CHC, CHW | 1960-1974 | 3B | 70.5 | Ron Santo | 48%
| |
| 270. | PIT, CHC, DET | 1912-1926 | LHP | 53.4 | Wilbur Cooper | 48%
|
| 130. | BRO, LAD | 1956-1969 | RHP | 67.1 | Don Drysdale | 45%
|
| 226. | SLB, WSH, BSN | 1915-1922; 1924-1930 | 1B | 57.2 | George Sisler | 45%
|
| TOR, NYM, SEA, NYY, BOS | 1989-2005 | 1B | 58.1 | John Olerud | 45%
| |
| 17. | BSN, STL, PHI | 1890-1901; 1904-1906 | RHP | 116.3 | Kid Nichols | 45%
|
| 237. | LAD, CLE, SFG, NYM, LAD | 1983-2000 | RHP | 56.0 | Orel Hershiser | 45%
|
| 97. | BAL, CAL | 1970-1986 | 2B | 71.0 | Bobby Grich | 41%
|
| TOR, CHW, TOR | 1979-1993; 1998 | RHP | 56.4 | Dave Stieb | 41%
| |
| DET, CLE | 1939-1955 | LHP | 62.8 | Hal Newhouser | 41%
| |
| 265. | TEX, DET, LAA, BOS, SDP | 2006-2019 | 2B | 53.8 | Ian Kinsler | 41%
|
| NYY, CLE | 1938-1943; 1946-1950 | 2B | 55.6 | Joe Gordon | 41%
| |
| 159. | CLE, BOS | 1938-1952 | SS | 63.1 | Lou Boudreau | 41%
|
| 136. | CLE, MIN, BOS, NYY, PIT, CAL | 1964-1982 | RHP | 66.1 | Luis Tiant | 41%
|
| CHW, DET | 1975-1990 | OF | 55.7 | Chet Lemon | 38%
| |
| CAL, ANA, CLE, STL | 1986-2002 | LHP | 57.9 | Chuck Finley | 38%
| |
| WSH, CLE, CHW, CLE | 1939; 1941-1944; 1946-1963 | RHP | 60.9 | Early Wynn | 38%
| |
| 94. | NYG, STL | 1919-1937 | 2B | 72.0 | Frankie Frisch | 38%
|
| 93. | DET, CIN | 1914; 1916-1930; 1932 | OF | 72.2 | Harry Heilmann | 38%
|
| 161. | PHA, NYY | 1908-1914; 1916-1919; 1921-1922 | 3B | 62.8 | Home Run Baker | 38%
|
| WSH, MIN, CHW, PHI, NYY, STL | 1959-1983 | LHP | 50.5 | Jim Kaat | 38%
| |
| HOU, LAD, ATL, NYY, MIL | 1963-1977 | OF | 55.9 | Jim Wynn | 38%
| |
| STL, BRO, NYG, BSN, BRO, STL | 1932-1948 | OF | 54.5 | Joe Medwick | 38%
| |
| 274. | CLE, CHW, CLE, CHW, STL, WSA, CHW | 1949; 1951-1964; 1976; 1980 | OF | 53.2 | Minnie Minoso | 38%
|
| 147. | PHI, CHC, NYM | 1948-1962 | OF | 64.3 | Richie Ashburn | 38%
|
| 98. | CHW | 1923-1942; 1946 | RHP | 70.7 | Ted Lyons | 38%
|
| BOS, PIT, CHW | 1961-1965; 1967-1978 | LHP | 50.0 | Wilbur Wood | 38%
| |
| 299. | BOS | 1937-1944; 1946-1951 | 2B | 51.3 | Bobby Doerr | 34%
|
| 302. | CLE, PIT, SDP | 1995-2009 | OF | 51.1 | Brian Giles | 34%
|
| PIT, NYY, BRO, STL, CIN, BRO | 1915; 1918; 1922-1935 | RHP | 60.4 | Dazzy Vance | 34%
| |
| 134. | CHW, BSN | 1904-1917 | RHP | 66.5 | Ed Walsh | 34%
|
| 224. | STL, NYY, KCA, NYY, MLN | 1938-1942; 1946-1959 | OF | 57.5 | Enos Slaughter | 34%
|
| 142. | PIT, WSH, BOS | 1926-1945 | SS | 64.8 | Joe Cronin | 34%
|
| STL, NYG, NYY | 1936-1942; 1946-1953 | 1B | 70.5 | Johnny Mize | 34%
| |
| 229. | CLE, CHW, CLE, DET, CHW | 1947-1959 | OF | 56.7 | Larry Doby | 34%
|
| PRO, BSN, BOS, CIN | 1881-1891 | RHP | 75.4 | Old Hoss Radbourn | 34%
| |
| 214. | LOU, PIT, CHC, PHA, SLB | 1897; 1899-1910 | LHP | 58.4 | Rube Waddell | 34%
|
| 116. | NYG | 1928-1943 | RHP | 68.5 | Carl Hubbell | 31%
|
| 249. | CHC, NYG | 1922-1941 | C | 55.5 | Gabby Hartnett | 31%
|
| 201. | DET, PHI, PIT, LAD, PHI | 1955-1971 | RHP | 59.4 | Jim Bunning | 31%
|
| BSN, PIT, BLN, BRO, BLA, CIN, BSN | 1891-1906; 1908 | OF | 50.4 | Joe Kelley | 31%
| |
| CHC, CIN, CHI, CHC | 1902-1916 | SS | 53.2 | Joe Tinker | 31%
| |
| 89. | STL, BUF, PIT, PBB, PIT, STL | 1875; 1879-1892 | RHP | 73.4 | Pud Galvin | 31%
|
| 107. | CHC, NYY, CHC, PIT, SFG | 1972-1981; 1983-1991 | RHP | 69.5 | Rick Reuschel | 31%
|
| 236. | CHW, NYM, NYY, LAD | 1989-2004 | 3B | 56.1 | Robin Ventura | 31%
|
| KCN, STL, CHI, PIT, NYG, CIN, WHS | 1886-1893; 1896-1897 | RHP | 50.4 | Silver King | 31%
| |
| BSN, PIT, STL | 1898-1910 | RHP | 63.2 | Vic Willis | 31%
| |
| 262. | NYG, BRO, BLN, BRO, NYY, NYG | 1892-1910 | OF | 54.3 | Willie Keeler | 31%
|
| NYG | 1923-1936 | 1B | 56.5 | Bill Terry | 28%
| |
| 70. | TRO, BUF, DTN, BSN, BOS, BRO, BLN, LOU, PHI, NYG | 1879-1896; 1904 | 1B | 78.7 | Dan Brouthers | 28%
|
| 295. | CLE, DET, BSN | 1929-1941 | OF | 51.6 | Earl Averill | 28%
|
| TRO, NYG | 1880-1892 | RHP | 62.3 | Mickey Welch | 28%
| |
| 290. | CHW, DET | 1958-1974 | 1B | 52.0 | Norm Cash | 28%
|
| 49. | TRO, NYP, NYG, PHI | 1880-1893 | RHP | 86.9 | Tim Keefe | 28%
|
| PIT, NYY, LAD, OAK, MIL, NYM | 1975-1992 | 2B | 65.9 | Willie Randolph | 28%
| |
| BRO, PHA | 1909-1927 | OF | 60.4 | Zack Wheat | 28%
| |
| 77. | CLV, STL, SLB, STL | 1894-1918 | SS | 76.4 | Bobby Wallace | 24%
|
| 106. | PHI, CLE, PHI, WSH | 1888-1903 | OF | 69.6 | Ed Delahanty | 24%
|
| 227. | CAL, BOS, TEX, DET, NYM, NYY | 1973-1993 | LHP | 57.1 | Frank Tanana | 24%
|
| 137. | WSH, SLB, WSH, DET, WSH | 1921-1938 | OF | 65.9 | Goose Goslin | 24%
|
| 252. | CLV, STL, SLB, NYY, SLB | 1897-1912 | RHP | 55.3 | Jack Powell | 24%
|
| STL, NYM, CHW, LAD | 1955-1969 | 3B | 62.8 | Ken Boyer | 24%
| |
| 258. | KCR, OAK, NYM, ANA, KCR | 1989-2004 | RHP | 54.5 | Kevin Appier | 24%
|
| SEA, MON, CAL, ANA, SDP, CLE | 1984-1999 | LHP | 50.1 | Mark Langston | 24%
| |
| 244. | PIT, BRO | 1910-1929 | OF | 55.6 | Max Carey | 24%
|
| 115. | BOS, NYY, CHW | 1924-1942; 1945-1947 | RHP | 68.6 | Red Ruffing | 24%
|
| 266. | LAD, CHC, OAK | 1971-1987 | 3B | 53.7 | Ron Cey | 24%
|
| NYG, BOS, NYY, DET, PHA, BRO, NYG, PIT, BRO | 1918-1938 | RHP | 52.4 | Waite Hoyt | 24%
| |
| 221. | CHC, BRO, BSN, PIT | 1931-1943; 1946-1947 | 2B | 57.6 | Billy Herman | 21%
|
| 280. | PIT, BRO, NYG, PIT, BSN, STL, CHC, STL, NYY, PIT | 1916-1934 | RHP | 52.9 | Burleigh Grimes | 21%
|
| HOU, CIN, STL, LAD | 1970-1986 | OF | 53.0 | Cesar Cedeno | 21%
| |
| 152. | CHW | 1914-1933 | RHP | 63.8 | Red Faber | 21%
|
| 177. | KCA, OAK, MIL | 1966-1981 | 3B | 61.5 | Sal Bando | 21%
|
| 282. | STL, PIT | 1906-1907; 1909-1916; 1918-1926 | RHP | 52.6 | Babe Adams | 17%
|
| DET, BOS, CHW | 1905; 1908-1920 | RHP | 59.0 | Eddie Cicotte | 17%
| |
| 268. | BOS, CHW | 1909-1925 | OF | 53.6 | Harry Hooper | 17%
|
| 179. | PIT, PBB, PIT, NYG, CIN, STL | 1888-1907 | 1B | 61.2 | Jake Beckley | 17%
|
| NYM, MIN, CHW, PHI | 1967-1985 | LHP | 53.7 | Jerry Koosman | 17%
| |
| BLN, BRO, BLA, NYG | 1899-1908 | RHP | 59.0 | Joe McGinnity | 17%
| |
| 59. | WOR, CHC, BSN, CLV | 1882; 1884-1894 | RHP | 83.2 | John Clarkson | 17%
|
| 173. | PHA, CLE, WSH, NYY | 1912; 1916-1928 | RHP | 61.9 | Stan Coveleski | 17%
|
| 263. | CIN, STL, CLE, CAL, KCR | 1958-1975 | OF | 54.0 | Vada Pinson | 17%
|
| 284. | CIN | 1882-1899 | 2B | 52.5 | Bid McPhee | 14%
|
| 82. | CHC, BRO, NYG, BSN, BRO | 1891-1911 | SS | 75.3 | Bill Dahlen | 14%
|
| 281. | PHI, PHA, CLE | 1898-1910 | OF | 52.7 | Elmer Flick | 14%
|
| 196. | NYG, CLV, STL, SLB, BOS | 1890-1905 | OF | 59.7 | Jesse Burkett | 14%
|
| 256. | CLE, NYY | 1920-1933 | SS | 54.9 | Joe Sewell | 14%
|
| PRO, NYG, BWW, BRO, NYG | 1878-1894 | SS | 62.3 | John Ward | 14%
| |
| OAK, DET, CAL, CHW, ANA, TOR, NYM, OAK | 1982-1999 | OF | 50.9 | Tony Phillips | 14%
| |
| 277. | KCA, OAK, TEX, CAL, NYY | 1964-1981; 1983 | SS | 53.0 | Bert Campaneris | 10%
|
| MAN, BOS, BSN, PRO, BSN, BUF, NYG, NYI, NYG, WHS, NYG | 1872-1893; 1904 | OF | 52.3 | Jim O'Rourke | 10%
| |
| 55. | TRO, NYG, NYI, NYG, PHI, NYG, STL | 1880-1897 | 1B | 84.3 | Roger Connor | 10%
|
| 194. | CLE, BOS, WSH, NYY, BRO, BSN | 1927-1941 | RHP | 60.1 | Wes Ferrell | 10%
|
| BOS, CHC | 1871-1877 | RHP | 60.2 | Al Spalding | 7%
| |
| DET, CHW, SFG | 1945; 1948-1964 | LHP | 53.4 | Billy Pierce | 7%
| |
| PHI, CIN, BSN | 1934-1948; 1950 | RHP | 53.6 | Bucky Walters | 7%
| |
| 178. | KCM | 1920-1929; 1937-1938 | RHP | 61.3 | Bullet Joe Rogan | 7%
|
| 239. | PHI, CIN | 1912-1917; 1919-1933 | LHP | 55.9 | Eppa Rixey | 7%
|
| NYY, SLB, NYY | 1916-1928 | RHP | 59.0 | Urban Shocker | 7%
| |
| PHI, WSH, NYY | 1895-1909 | RHP | 51.3 | Al Orth | 3%
| |
| 140. | IND, NYG, CIN | 1889-1895; 1897-1898; 1901 | RHP | 65.8 | Amos Rusie | 3%
|
| STL, BRO, STL | 1884-1892 | RHP | 59.5 | Bob Caruthers | 3%
| |
| STL, BOS, CHC, CHW, NYY, CIN, WSH | 1891; 1893-1907; 1909; 1912-1914 | RHP | 63.8 | Clark Griffith | 3%
| |
| CLE, DET, NYG, NYY, CLE | 1919-1934; 1936 | RHP | 55.6 | George Uhle | 3%
| |
| 212. | NYY, BSN, BAL, CHW, NYY, BOS, PHA, BRO, CIN | 1909-1915; 1918-1933 | RHP | 58.6 | Jack Quinn | 3%
|
| 78. | IND, CLV, COR, PRO, CHC, PIT | 1878-1887 | RHP | 76.2 | Jim McCormick | 3%
|
| PHI, BSN, CIN | 1904-1919 | OF | 59.4 | Sherry Magee | 3%
| |
| 253. | CHC | 1932-1947 | 3B | 55.2 | Stan Hack | 3%
|
| 306. | STL, CIN, STL | 1891-1901 | LHP | 50.6 | Theodore Breitenstein | 3%
|
| 298. | WSA, TEX, CLE, NYY, TEX | 1969; 1971-1986 | 3B | 51.4 | Toby Harrah | 3%
|
| 304. | PIT, BSN, NYG, SLB, CHW | 1939-1953 | 3B | 50.9 | Bob Elliott | 0%
|
| 297. | CHW, CAL, TEX | 1973-1992 | OF | 51.5 | Brian Downing | 0%
|
| 183. | BSN, PHI, PHO, BOS, BLN | 1882-1892 | RHP | 60.7 | Charlie Buffinton | 0%
|
| 175. | CLV, COR, SLM, IND, NYG, STL, PIT, LOU, WHS | 1879-1895 | SS | 61.6 | Jack Glasscock | 0%
|
| BSN, KCN, WHS, IND, PHA | 1881-1890 | RHP | 56.0 | Jim Whitney | 0%
| |
| 312. | DET | 1930-1943; 1945-1946 | RHP | 50.4 | Tommy Bridges | 0%
|
| 133. | DTN, LOU, STL, TOL, CIN, BLN, CLV | 1881-1884; 1886-1894 | RHP | 66.6 | Tony Mullane | 0%
|