| League | Year | Place | Team | Position | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AL | 2017 | 2. | NYY | RF | Aaron Judge | 91%
|
| AL | 2021 | 4. | NYY | RF | Aaron Judge | 91%
|
| AL | 2022 | 1. | NYY | RF | Aaron Judge | 91%
|
| AL | 2024 | 1. | NYY | CF | Aaron Judge | 91%
|
| AL | 2025 | 1. | NYY | RF | Aaron Judge | 91%
|
| AL | 2001 | 6. | TEX | SS | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2002 | 2. | TEX | SS | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2003 | 1. | TEX | SS | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2005 | 1. | NYY | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2007 | 1. | NYY | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2008 | 8. | NYY | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | 89%
|
| AL | 2021 | 1. | LAA | DH/SP | Shohei Ohtani | 89%
|
| AL | 2022 | 2. | LAA | DH/SP | Shohei Ohtani | 89%
|
| AL | 2023 | 1. | LAA | DH/SP | Shohei Ohtani | 89%
|
| NL | 2024 | 1. | LAD | DH | Shohei Ohtani | 89%
|
| NL | 2025 | 1. | LAD | DH/SP | Shohei Ohtani | 89%
|
| NL | 2015 | 1. | WSN | RF | Bryce Harper | 87%
|
| NL | 2021 | 1. | PHI | RF | Bryce Harper | 87%
|
| NL | 2024 | 6. | PHI | 1B | Bryce Harper | 87%
|
| AL | 2008 | 6. | LAA | RP | Francisco Rodriguez | 87%
|
| AL | 2004 | 10. | DET | C | Ivan Rodriguez | 87%
|
| AL | 2022 | 7. | SEA | CF | Julio Rodriguez | 87%
|
| AL | 2023 | 4. | SEA | CF | Julio Rodriguez | 87%
|
| AL | 2025 | 6. | SEA | CF | Julio Rodriguez | 87%
|
| AL | 2012 | 2. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2013 | 2. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2014 | 1. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2015 | 2. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2016 | 1. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2017 | 4. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2018 | 2. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2019 | 1. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2020 | 5. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| AL | 2022 | 8. | LAA | CF | Mike Trout | 87%
|
| NL | 2002 | 4. | MON | RF | Vladimir Guerrero | 87%
|
| AL | 2004 | 1. | ANA | RF | Vladimir Guerrero | 87%
|
| AL | 2005 | 3. | LAA | RF | Vladimir Guerrero | 87%
|
| AL | 2006 | 9. | LAA | RF | Vladimir Guerrero | 87%
|
| AL | 2007 | 3. | LAA | RF | Vladimir Guerrero | 87%
|
| AL | 2021 | 2. | TOR | 1B | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | 87%
|
| AL | 2024 | 6. | TOR | 1B | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | 87%
|
| NL | 2004 | 10. | CHC | 3B | Aramis Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2008 | 10. | CHC | 3B | Aramis Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2012 | 9. | MIL | 3B | Aramis Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2003 | 5. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2004 | 4. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2005 | 2. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2006 | 3. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2007 | 4. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2013 | 10. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| AL | 2016 | 6. | BOS | DH | David Ortiz | 84%
|
| NL | 2007 | 10. | FLA | SS | Hanley Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2009 | 2. | FLA | SS | Hanley Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2013 | 8. | LAD | SS | Hanley Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2015 | 10. | HOU | 2B | Jose Altuve | 84%
|
| AL | 2016 | 3. | HOU | 2B | Jose Altuve | 84%
|
| AL | 2017 | 1. | HOU | 2B | Jose Altuve | 84%
|
| AL | 2022 | 5. | HOU | 2B | Jose Altuve | 84%
|
| AL | 2017 | 3. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2018 | 3. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2020 | 2. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2021 | 6. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2022 | 4. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2023 | 10. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2024 | 5. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2025 | 3. | CLE | 3B | Jose Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2011 | 1. | DET | SP | Justin Verlander | 84%
|
| AL | 2012 | 8. | DET | SP | Justin Verlander | 84%
|
| AL | 2018 | 10. | HOU | SP | Justin Verlander | 84%
|
| AL | 2022 | 10. | HOU | SP | Justin Verlander | 84%
|
| AL | 2013 | 9. | BAL | 3B | Manny Machado | 84%
|
| AL | 2015 | 4. | BAL | 3B | Manny Machado | 84%
|
| AL | 2016 | 5. | BAL | 3B | Manny Machado | 84%
|
| NL | 2020 | 3. | SDP | 3B | Manny Machado | 84%
|
| NL | 2022 | 2. | SDP | 3B | Manny Machado | 84%
|
| AL | 2001 | 9. | BOS | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2002 | 9. | BOS | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2003 | 6. | BOS | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2004 | 3. | BOS | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| AL | 2005 | 4. | BOS | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2008 | 4. | LAD | LF | Manny Ramirez | 84%
|
| NL | 2013 | 2. | ARI | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2015 | 2. | ARI | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2017 | 3. | ARI | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2018 | 6. | ARI | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2021 | 6. | STL | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2022 | 1. | STL | 1B | Paul Goldschmidt | 84%
|
| NL | 2020 | 4. | SDP | SS | Fernando Tatis Jr. | 82%
|
| NL | 2021 | 3. | SDP | SS | Fernando Tatis Jr. | 82%
|
| NL | 2025 | 8. | SDP | RF | Fernando Tatis Jr. | 82%
|
| NL | 2013 | 5. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2016 | 6. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2018 | 4. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2019 | 8. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2020 | 1. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2021 | 9. | ATL | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2022 | 4. | LAD | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| NL | 2023 | 3. | LAD | 1B | Freddie Freeman | 82%
|
| AL | 2001 | 1. | SEA | RF | Ichiro Suzuki | 82%
|
| AL | 2004 | 7. | SEA | RF | Ichiro Suzuki | 82%
|
| AL | 2007 | 8. | SEA | CF | Ichiro Suzuki | 82%
|
| AL | 2009 | 9. | SEA | RF | Ichiro Suzuki | 82%
|
| NL | 2019 | 5. | ATL | CF | Ronald Acuna Jr. | 82%
|
| NL | 2023 | 1. | ATL | RF | Ronald Acuna Jr. | 82%
|
| NL | 2001 | 4. | STL | 3B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2002 | 2. | STL | LF | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2003 | 2. | STL | LF | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2004 | 3. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2005 | 1. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2006 | 2. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2007 | 9. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2008 | 1. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2009 | 1. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2010 | 2. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| NL | 2011 | 5. | STL | 1B | Albert Pujols | 80%
|
| AL | 2018 | 5. | HOU | 3B | Alex Bregman | 80%
|
| AL | 2019 | 2. | HOU | 3B | Alex Bregman | 80%
|
| NL | 2001 | 1. | SFG | LF | Barry Bonds | 80%
|
| NL | 2002 | 1. | SFG | LF | Barry Bonds | 80%
|
| NL | 2003 | 1. | SFG | LF | Barry Bonds | 80%
|
| NL | 2004 | 1. | SFG | LF | Barry Bonds | 80%
|
| NL | 2018 | 1. | MIL | LF | Christian Yelich | 80%
|
| NL | 2019 | 2. | MIL | RF | Christian Yelich | 80%
|
| NL | 2013 | 7. | LAD | SP | Clayton Kershaw | 80%
|
| NL | 2014 | 1. | LAD | SP | Clayton Kershaw | 80%
|
| NL | 2015 | 10. | LAD | SP | Clayton Kershaw | 80%
|
| NL | 2017 | 9. | LAD | RF | Cody Bellinger | 80%
|
| NL | 2019 | 1. | LAD | RF | Cody Bellinger | 80%
|
| NL | 2023 | 10. | CHC | CF | Cody Bellinger | 80%
|
| NL | 2016 | 9. | LAD | 3B | Justin Turner | 80%
|
| NL | 2017 | 8. | LAD | 3B | Justin Turner | 80%
|
| AL | 2016 | 2. | BOS | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| AL | 2017 | 6. | BOS | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| AL | 2018 | 1. | BOS | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| AL | 2019 | 8. | BOS | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| NL | 2020 | 2. | LAD | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| NL | 2022 | 5. | LAD | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| NL | 2023 | 2. | LAD | RF | Mookie Betts | 80%
|
| NL | 2020 | 7. | WSN | SS | Trea Turner | 80%
|
| NL | 2021 | 5. | WSN/LAD | SS | Trea Turner | 80%
|
| NL | 2025 | 5. | PHI | SS | Trea Turner | 80%
|
| NL | 2016 | 3. | LAD | SS | Corey Seager | 78%
|
| NL | 2020 | 9. | LAD | SS | Corey Seager | 78%
|
| AL | 2023 | 2. | TEX | SS | Corey Seager | 78%
|
| AL | 2001 | 10. | NYY | SS | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| AL | 2005 | 10. | NYY | SS | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| AL | 2006 | 2. | NYY | SS | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| AL | 2009 | 3. | NYY | SS | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| AL | 2012 | 7. | NYY | SS | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| AL | 2016 | T9. | CLE | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| AL | 2017 | 5. | CLE | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| AL | 2018 | 6. | CLE | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| NL | 2022 | 9. | NYM | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| NL | 2023 | 9. | NYM | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| NL | 2024 | 2. | NYM | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| NL | 2025 | 10. | NYM | SS | Francisco Lindor | 78%
|
| NL | 2014 | 2. | MIA | RF | Giancarlo Stanton | 78%
|
| NL | 2017 | 1. | MIA | RF | Giancarlo Stanton | 78%
|
| NL | 2019 | 9. | WSN | LF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| NL | 2020 | 5. | WSN | LF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| NL | 2021 | 2. | WSN | RF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| NL | 2023 | 6. | SDP | LF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| AL | 2024 | 3. | NYY | RF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| NL | 2025 | 3. | NYM | RF | Juan Soto | 78%
|
| NL | 2015 | 8. | COL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2016 | 5. | COL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2017 | 4. | COL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2018 | 3. | COL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2019 | 6. | COL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2022 | 3. | STL | 3B | Nolan Arenado | 78%
|
| NL | 2019 | 7. | NYM | 1B | Pete Alonso | 78%
|
| NL | 2022 | 8. | NYM | 1B | Pete Alonso | 78%
|
| NL | 2010 | 1. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2011 | 6. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2013 | 6. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2015 | 3. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2016 | 7. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2017 | 2. | CIN | 1B | Joey Votto | 76%
|
| NL | 2003 | 10. | FLA | CF | Juan Pierre | 76%
|
| NL | 2016 | 10. | WSN | SP | Max Scherzer | 76%
|
| NL | 2017 | 10. | WSN | SP | Max Scherzer | 76%
|
| NL | 2018 | 10. | WSN | SP | Max Scherzer | 76%
|
| NL | 2005 | 5. | FLA | LF | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| NL | 2006 | 5. | FLA | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2009 | 4. | DET | 1B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2010 | 2. | DET | 1B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2011 | 5. | DET | 1B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2012 | 1. | DET | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2013 | 1. | DET | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2014 | 9. | DET | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2016 | T9. | DET | 3B | Miguel Cabrera | 76%
|
| AL | 2021 | 7. | KCR | C | Salvador Perez | 76%
|
| NL | 2014 | 10. | CHC | 1B | Anthony Rizzo | 73%
|
| NL | 2015 | 4. | CHC | 1B | Anthony Rizzo | 73%
|
| NL | 2016 | 4. | CHC | 1B | Anthony Rizzo | 73%
|
| AL | 2017 | 9. | BOS | SP | Chris Sale | 73%
|
| NL | 2024 | 7. | ATL | SP | Chris Sale | 73%
|
| NL | 2024 | 8. | CIN | SS | Elly De La Cruz | 73%
|
| AL | 2014 | 4. | CHW | 1B | Jose Abreu | 73%
|
| AL | 2020 | 1. | CHW | 1B | Jose Abreu | 73%
|
| AL | 2013 | 4. | OAK | 3B | Josh Donaldson | 73%
|
| AL | 2014 | 8. | OAK | 3B | Josh Donaldson | 73%
|
| AL | 2015 | 1. | TOR | 3B | Josh Donaldson | 73%
|
| AL | 2016 | 4. | TOR | 3B | Josh Donaldson | 73%
|
| NL | 2016 | 1. | CHC | 3B | Kris Bryant | 73%
|
| NL | 2017 | 7. | CHC | 3B | Kris Bryant | 73%
|
| NL | 2025 | 2. | PHI | DH | Kyle Schwarber | 73%
|
| NL | 2001 | 2. | CHC | RF | Sammy Sosa | 73%
|
| NL | 2002 | 9. | CHC | RF | Sammy Sosa | 73%
|
| NL | 2003 | 8. | CHC | RF | Sammy Sosa | 73%
|
| NL | 2012 | 3. | PIT | CF | Andrew McCutchen | 71%
|
| NL | 2013 | 1. | PIT | CF | Andrew McCutchen | 71%
|
| NL | 2014 | 3. | PIT | CF | Andrew McCutchen | 71%
|
| NL | 2015 | 5. | PIT | CF | Andrew McCutchen | 71%
|
| NL | 2012 | 1. | SFG | C | Buster Posey | 71%
|
| NL | 2014 | 6. | SFG | C | Buster Posey | 71%
|
| NL | 2015 | 9. | SFG | C | Buster Posey | 71%
|
| AL | 2025 | 2. | SEA | C | Cal Raleigh | 71%
|
| AL | 2007 | 9. | TBD | 1B | Carlos Pena | 71%
|
| AL | 2008 | 9. | TBR | 1B | Carlos Pena | 71%
|
| AL | 2019 | 7. | HOU | CF | George Springer | 71%
|
| AL | 2025 | 7. | TOR | CF | George Springer | 71%
|
| NL | 2018 | 5. | NYM | SP | Jacob deGrom | 71%
|
| NL | 2019 | 10. | NYM | SP | Jacob deGrom | 71%
|
| AL | 2025 | 10. | HOU | SS | Jeremy Pena | 71%
|
| NL | 2025 | T6. | PIT | SP | Paul Skenes | 71%
|
| AL | 2022 | 3. | HOU | DH | Yordan Alvarez | 71%
|
| AL | 2024 | 9. | HOU | DH | Yordan Alvarez | 71%
|
| AL | 2023 | 7. | KCR | SS | Bobby Witt Jr. | 69%
|
| AL | 2024 | 2. | KCR | SS | Bobby Witt Jr. | 69%
|
| AL | 2025 | 4. | KCR | SS | Bobby Witt Jr. | 69%
|
| AL | 2020 | 8. | TBR | 2B | Brandon Lowe | 69%
|
| AL | 2021 | 10. | TBR | 2B | Brandon Lowe | 69%
|
| AL | 2023 | 8. | BAL | 3B | Gunnar Henderson | 69%
|
| AL | 2024 | 4. | BAL | SS | Gunnar Henderson | 69%
|
| AL | 2010 | 3. | NYY | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2011 | 6. | NYY | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2012 | 4. | NYY | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2013 | 5. | NYY | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2014 | 5. | SEA | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2016 | 8. | SEA | 2B | Robinson Cano | 69%
|
| AL | 2024 | 7. | DET | SP | Tarik Skubal | 69%
|
| AL | 2025 | 5. | DET | SP | Tarik Skubal | 69%
|
| NL | 2014 | 5. | WSN | 3B | Anthony Rendon | 67%
|
| NL | 2017 | 6. | WSN | 3B | Anthony Rendon | 67%
|
| NL | 2019 | 3. | WSN | 3B | Anthony Rendon | 67%
|
| AL | 2020 | 10. | LAA | 3B | Anthony Rendon | 67%
|
| AL | 2021 | 5. | HOU | SS | Carlos Correa | 67%
|
| AL | 2014 | 10. | SEA | SP | Felix Hernandez | 67%
|
| AL | 2006 | 6. | MIN | C | Joe Mauer | 67%
|
| AL | 2008 | 4. | MIN | C | Joe Mauer | 67%
|
| AL | 2009 | 1. | MIN | C | Joe Mauer | 67%
|
| AL | 2010 | 8. | MIN | C | Joe Mauer | 67%
|
| AL | 2023 | 5. | HOU | RF | Kyle Tucker | 67%
|
| AL | 2019 | 3. | OAK | SS | Marcus Semien | 67%
|
| AL | 2021 | 3. | TOR | 2B | Marcus Semien | 67%
|
| AL | 2023 | 3. | TEX | 2B | Marcus Semien | 67%
|
| AL | 2021 | 8. | OAK | 1B | Matt Olson | 67%
|
| NL | 2023 | 4. | ATL | 1B | Matt Olson | 67%
|
| AL | 2014 | 7. | BAL | DH | Nelson Cruz | 67%
|
| AL | 2015 | 6. | SEA | DH | Nelson Cruz | 67%
|
| AL | 2017 | 10. | SEA | DH | Nelson Cruz | 67%
|
| AL | 2019 | 9. | MIN | DH | Nelson Cruz | 67%
|
| AL | 2020 | 6. | MIN | DH | Nelson Cruz | 67%
|
| AL | 2012 | 6. | BAL | CF | Adam Jones | 64%
|
| NL | 2005 | 2. | ATL | CF | Andruw Jones | 64%
|
| NL | 2021 | 7. | ATL | 3B | Austin Riley | 64%
|
| NL | 2022 | 6. | ATL | 3B | Austin Riley | 64%
|
| NL | 2023 | 7. | ATL | 3B | Austin Riley | 64%
|
| NL | 2010 | 3. | COL | RF | Carlos Gonzalez | 64%
|
| NL | 2001 | 8. | ATL | 3B | Chipper Jones | 64%
|
| NL | 2007 | 6. | ATL | 3B | Chipper Jones | 64%
|
| AL | 2013 | 3. | BAL | 1B | Chris Davis | 64%
|
| NL | 2023 | 5. | ARI | LF | Corbin Carroll | 64%
|
| NL | 2025 | T6. | ARI | LF | Corbin Carroll | 64%
|
| AL | 2002 | 4. | ANA | LF | Garret Anderson | 64%
|
| AL | 2019 | 10. | HOU | SP | Gerrit Cole | 64%
|
| AL | 2024 | 8. | BOS | CF | Jarren Duran | 64%
|
| NL | 2019 | 4. | ARI | CF | Ketel Marte | 64%
|
| NL | 2024 | 3. | ARI | CF | Ketel Marte | 64%
|
| AL | 2018 | 8. | OAK | DH | Khris Davis | 64%
|
| NL | 2020 | 6. | ATL | DH | Marcell Ozuna | 64%
|
| NL | 2024 | 4. | ATL | DH | Marcell Ozuna | 64%
|
| NL | 2008 | 3. | MIL | LF | Ryan Braun | 64%
|
| NL | 2011 | 1. | MIL | LF | Ryan Braun | 64%
|
| NL | 2012 | 2. | MIL | LF | Ryan Braun | 64%
|
| AL | 2020 | 7. | CHW | SS | Tim Anderson | 64%
|
| NL | 2018 | 8. | COL | SS | Trevor Story | 64%
|
| NL | 2012 | 4. | STL | C | Yadier Molina | 64%
|
| NL | 2013 | 3. | STL | C | Yadier Molina | 64%
|
| NL | 2010 | 4. | SDP | 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | 62%
|
| AL | 2011 | 7. | BOS | 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | 62%
|
| NL | 2014 | 7. | LAD | 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | 62%
|
| NL | 2021 | 4. | SFG | SS | Brandon Crawford | 62%
|
| AL | 2010 | 7. | TBR | LF | Carl Crawford | 62%
|
| AL | 2019 | 4. | NYY | 2B | DJ LeMahieu | 62%
|
| AL | 2020 | 3. | NYY | 2B | DJ LeMahieu | 62%
|
| AL | 2008 | 1. | BOS | 2B | Dustin Pedroia | 62%
|
| AL | 2011 | 9. | BOS | 2B | Dustin Pedroia | 62%
|
| AL | 2013 | T7. | BOS | 2B | Dustin Pedroia | 62%
|
| AL | 2001 | 2. | OAK | 1B | Jason Giambi | 62%
|
| AL | 2002 | 5. | NYY | 1B | Jason Giambi | 62%
|
| NL | 2022 | 7. | PHI | C | JT Realmuto | 62%
|
| AL | 2001 | 5. | CLE | RF | Juan Gonzalez | 62%
|
| NL | 2001 | 3. | ARI | LF | Luis Gonzalez | 62%
|
| AL | 2018 | 7. | OAK | 3B | Matt Chapman | 62%
|
| AL | 2019 | 6. | OAK | 3B | Matt Chapman | 62%
|
| NL | 2002 | 7. | ARI | SP | Randy Johnson | 62%
|
| AL | 2020 | 4. | CLE | SP | Shane Bieber | 62%
|
| NL | 2024 | 5. | MIL | C | William Contreras | 62%
|
| AL | 2023 | 9. | BAL | C | Adley Rutschman | 60%
|
| NL | 2004 | 2. | LAD | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| AL | 2010 | 9. | BOS | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| AL | 2012 | 3. | TEX | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| AL | 2013 | T7. | TEX | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| AL | 2015 | 7. | TEX | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| AL | 2016 | 7. | TEX | 3B | Adrian Beltre | 60%
|
| NL | 2018 | 2. | CHC | SS | Javier Baez | 60%
|
| AL | 2018 | 4. | BOS | DH | JD Martinez | 60%
|
| AL | 2008 | 7. | TEX | CF | Josh Hamilton | 60%
|
| AL | 2010 | 1. | TEX | CF | Josh Hamilton | 60%
|
| AL | 2012 | 5. | TEX | CF | Josh Hamilton | 60%
|
| AL | 2004 | 9. | NYY | RP | Mariano Rivera | 60%
|
| AL | 2005 | 9. | NYY | RP | Mariano Rivera | 60%
|
| NL | 2025 | 9. | CHC | CF | Pete Crow-Armstrong | 60%
|
| NL | 2006 | 1. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2007 | 5. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2008 | 2. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2009 | 3. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2010 | 10. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2011 | 10. | PHI | 1B | Ryan Howard | 60%
|
| NL | 2004 | 4. | STL | 3B | Scott Rolen | 60%
|
| AL | 2007 | 7. | CLE | C | Victor Martinez | 60%
|
| AL | 2014 | 2. | DET | DH | Victor Martinez | 60%
|
| AL | 2019 | 5. | BOS | SS | Xander Bogaerts | 60%
|
| AL | 2022 | 9. | BOS | SS | Xander Bogaerts | 60%
|
| AL | 2024 | 10. | OAK | DH | Brent Rooker | 58%
|
| AL | 2021 | 9. | BAL | CF | Cedric Mullins | 58%
|
| AL | 2025 | 8. | BOS | SP | Garrett Crochet | 58%
|
| NL | 2015 | 6. | CHC | SP | Jake Arrieta | 58%
|
| AL | 2010 | 4. | TOR | RF | Jose Bautista | 58%
|
| AL | 2011 | 3. | TOR | RF | Jose Bautista | 58%
|
| AL | 2014 | 6. | TOR | RF | Jose Bautista | 58%
|
| AL | 2015 | 8. | TOR | RF | Jose Bautista | 58%
|
| NL | 2022 | 10. | MIA | SP | Sandy Alcantara | 58%
|
| NL | 2009 | 5. | COL | SS | Troy Tulowitzki | 58%
|
| NL | 2010 | 5. | COL | SS | Troy Tulowitzki | 58%
|
| NL | 2011 | 8. | COL | SS | Troy Tulowitzki | 58%
|
| NL | 2017 | 5. | COL | CF | Charlie Blackmon | 56%
|
| NL | 2006 | 9. | NYM | 3B | David Wright | 56%
|
| NL | 2007 | 4. | NYM | 3B | David Wright | 56%
|
| NL | 2008 | 7. | NYM | 3B | David Wright | 56%
|
| NL | 2012 | T6. | NYM | 3B | David Wright | 56%
|
| AL | 2010 | 6. | TBR | 3B | Evan Longoria | 56%
|
| AL | 2011 | 10. | TBR | 3B | Evan Longoria | 56%
|
| AL | 2013 | 6. | TBR | 3B | Evan Longoria | 56%
|
| AL | 2006 | 4. | OAK | DH | Frank Thomas | 56%
|
| NL | 2025 | 4. | ARI | SS | Geraldo Perdomo | 56%
|
| AL | 2025 | 9. | TBR | 3B | Junior Caminero | 56%
|
| AL | 2023 | 6. | TBR | 1B | Yandy Diaz | 56%
|
| AL | 2015 | 9. | DET/TOR | SP | David Price | 53%
|
| NL | 2024 | 9. | SDP | CF | Jackson Merrill | 53%
|
| NL | 2001 | 7. | HOU | 1B | Jeff Bagwell | 53%
|
| NL | 2005 | 10. | PHI | SS | Jimmy Rollins | 53%
|
| NL | 2007 | 1. | PHI | SS | Jimmy Rollins | 53%
|
| AL | 2004 | 6. | MIN | SP | Johan Santana | 53%
|
| AL | 2006 | 7. | MIN | SP | Johan Santana | 53%
|
| AL | 2005 | 7. | TEX | 1B | Mark Teixeira | 53%
|
| AL | 2009 | 2. | NYY | 1B | Mark Teixeira | 53%
|
| NL | 2009 | 10. | LAD | CF | Matt Kemp | 53%
|
| NL | 2011 | 2. | LAD | CF | Matt Kemp | 53%
|
| NL | 2007 | 3. | MIL | 1B | Prince Fielder | 53%
|
| NL | 2009 | 4. | MIL | 1B | Prince Fielder | 53%
|
| NL | 2011 | 3. | MIL | 1B | Prince Fielder | 53%
|
| AL | 2012 | 9. | DET | 1B | Prince Fielder | 53%
|
| NL | 2001 | 9. | COL | 1B | Todd Helton | 53%
|
| NL | 2003 | 7. | COL | 1B | Todd Helton | 53%
|
| NL | 2020 | 10. | CIN | SP | Trevor Bauer | 53%
|
| NL | 2024 | 10. | MIL | SS | Willy Adames | 53%
|
| AL | 2002 | 10. | NYY | CF | Bernie Williams | 51%
|
| NL | 2006 | T7. | PHI | 2B | Chase Utley | 51%
|
| NL | 2007 | 8. | PHI | 2B | Chase Utley | 51%
|
| NL | 2009 | 8. | PHI | 2B | Chase Utley | 51%
|
| AL | 2017 | 7. | CLE | SP | Corey Kluber | 51%
|
| AL | 2003 | 3. | NYY | C | Jorge Posada | 51%
|
| AL | 2007 | 6. | NYY | C | Jorge Posada | 51%
|
| NL | 2005 | 3. | CHC | 1B | Derrek Lee | 49%
|
| NL | 2009 | 9. | CHC | 1B | Derrek Lee | 49%
|
| NL | 2002 | 6. | SFG | 2B | Jeff Kent | 49%
|
| AL | 2006 | 1. | MIN | 1B | Justin Morneau | 49%
|
| AL | 2008 | 2. | MIN | 1B | Justin Morneau | 49%
|
| AL | 2015 | 3. | KCR | CF | Lorenzo Cain | 49%
|
| NL | 2018 | 7. | MIL | CF | Lorenzo Cain | 49%
|
| AL | 2001 | 8. | NYY | SP | Roger Clemens | 49%
|
| NL | 2004 | 8. | HOU | SP | Roger Clemens | 49%
|
| NL | 2014 | 8. | STL | SP | Adam Wainwright | 47%
|
| AL | 2003 | 9. | KCR | CF | Carlos Beltran | 47%
|
| NL | 2006 | 4. | NYM | CF | Carlos Beltran | 47%
|
| NL | 2008 | 6. | MIL | SP | CC Sabathia | 47%
|
| NL | 2005 | 8. | STL | SP | Chris Carpenter | 47%
|
| AL | 2001 | 7. | CLE | 1B | Jim Thome | 47%
|
| AL | 2002 | 7. | CLE | 1B | Jim Thome | 47%
|
| NL | 2003 | 4. | PHI | 1B | Jim Thome | 47%
|
| NL | 2023 | 8. | MIA | 2B | Luis Arraez | 47%
|
| NL | 2013 | 4. | STL | 2B | Matt Carpenter | 47%
|
| NL | 2018 | 9. | STL | 1B | Matt Carpenter | 47%
|
| NL | 2021 | 10. | LAD | 1B | Max Muncy | 47%
|
| NL | 2001 | 6. | LAD | RF | Shawn Green | 47%
|
| NL | 2002 | 5. | LAD | RF | Shawn Green | 47%
|
| AL | 2022 | 6. | CLE | 2B | Andres Gimenez | 44%
|
| AL | 2018 | 9. | TBR | SP | Blake Snell | 44%
|
| AL | 2020 | 9. | NYY | 1B | Luke Voit | 44%
|
| AL | 2002 | 1. | OAK | SS | Miguel Tejada | 44%
|
| AL | 2004 | 5. | BAL | SS | Miguel Tejada | 44%
|
| NL | 2010 | 6. | PHI | SP | Roy Halladay | 44%
|
| NL | 2011 | 9. | PHI | SP | Roy Halladay | 44%
|
| AL | 2003 | 2. | TOR | 1B | Carlos Delgado | 42%
|
| NL | 2005 | 6. | FLA | 1B | Carlos Delgado | 42%
|
| NL | 2008 | 9. | NYM | 1B | Carlos Delgado | 42%
|
| AL | 2005 | 6. | CHW | 1B | Paul Konerko | 42%
|
| AL | 2010 | 5. | CHW | 1B | Paul Konerko | 42%
|
| NL | 2001 | 10. | ARI | SP | Curt Schilling | 40%
|
| NL | 2002 | 10. | ARI | SP | Curt Schilling | 40%
|
| AL | 2011 | 2. | BOS | CF | Jacoby Ellsbury | 40%
|
| AL | 2017 | 8. | LAA | SS | Andrelton Simmons | 38%
|
| AL | 2015 | 5. | HOU | SP | Dallas Keuchel | 38%
|
| AL | 2010 | 10. | MIN | LF | Delmon Young | 38%
|
| NL | 2001 | 5. | HOU | LF | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| NL | 2002 | 3. | HOU | CF | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| NL | 2004 | 7. | HOU | CF | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| NL | 2006 | 3. | HOU | 1B | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| NL | 2008 | 5. | HOU | 1B | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| NL | 2011 | 7. | STL | RF | Lance Berkman | 38%
|
| AL | 2004 | 8. | TEX | SS | Michael Young | 38%
|
| AL | 2011 | 8. | TEX | DH | Michael Young | 38%
|
| AL | 2002 | 3. | NYY | 2B | Alfonso Soriano | 36%
|
| NL | 2006 | 6. | WSN | LF | Alfonso Soriano | 36%
|
| AL | 2003 | 7. | BOS | SS | Nomar Garciaparra | 36%
|
| AL | 2007 | 10. | DET | CF | Curtis Granderson | 33%
|
| AL | 2011 | 4. | NYY | CF | Curtis Granderson | 33%
|
| NL | 2002 | 8. | ATL | RP | John Smoltz | 33%
|
| NL | 2007 | 2. | COL | LF | Matt Holliday | 33%
|
| AL | 2001 | 4. | CLE | 2B | Roberto Alomar | 33%
|
| NL | 2015 | 7. | LAD | SP | Zack Greinke | 33%
|
| NL | 2003 | 6. | LAD | RP | Eric Gagne | 31%
|
| NL | 2003 | 3. | ATL | RF | Gary Sheffield | 31%
|
| AL | 2004 | 2. | NYY | RF | Gary Sheffield | 31%
|
| AL | 2005 | 8. | NYY | RF | Gary Sheffield | 31%
|
| NL | 2006 | T7. | NYM | SS | Jose Reyes | 31%
|
| AL | 2002 | 8. | CHW | RF | Magglio Ordonez | 31%
|
| AL | 2007 | 2. | DET | RF | Magglio Ordonez | 31%
|
| NL | 2012 | 8. | ATL | RP | Craig Kimbrel | 29%
|
| NL | 2010 | 8. | PHI | RF | Jayson Werth | 29%
|
| NL | 2004 | 5. | STL | CF | Jim Edmonds | 29%
|
| NL | 2006 | 10. | SDP | RP | Trevor Hoffman | 29%
|
| NL | 2016 | 2. | WSN | 2B | Daniel Murphy | 27%
|
| AL | 2006 | 5. | CHW | RF | Jermaine Dye | 27%
|
| NL | 2014 | 4. | MIL | C | Jonathan Lucroy | 27%
|
| AL | 2014 | 3. | CLE | LF | Michael Brantley | 27%
|
| NL | 2009 | 7. | SFG | 3B | Pablo Sandoval | 27%
|
| AL | 2002 | 6. | MIN | CF | Torii Hunter | 27%
|
| AL | 2003 | 8. | TOR | CF | Vernon Wells | 27%
|
| AL | 2012 | 10. | OAK | LF | Yoenis Cespedes | 27%
|
| NL | 2016 | 8. | NYM | LF | Yoenis Cespedes | 27%
|
| AL | 2009 | 8. | TBR | 2B | Ben Zobrist | 24%
|
| AL | 2008 | 10. | CLE | CF | Grady Sizemore | 24%
|
| NL | 2007 | 7. | SDP | SP | Jake Peavy | 24%
|
| NL | 2003 | 5. | ATL | C | Javy Lopez | 24%
|
| NL | 2012 | 10. | CIN | RF | Jay Bruce | 24%
|
| NL | 2013 | 10. | CIN | RF | Jay Bruce | 24%
|
| NL | 2021 | 8. | STL | LF | Tyler O'Neill | 24%
|
| AL | 2001 | 3. | SEA | 2B | Bret Boone | 22%
|
| AL | 2003 | 10. | SEA | 2B | Bret Boone | 22%
|
| NL | 2013 | 9. | MIL | CF | Carlos Gomez | 22%
|
| NL | 2012 | 5. | SDP | 3B | Chase Headley | 22%
|
| AL | 2008 | 3. | BOS | 1B | Kevin Youkilis | 22%
|
| AL | 2009 | 6. | BOS | 1B | Kevin Youkilis | 22%
|
| NL | 2012 | T6. | WSN | 1B | Adam LaRoche | 20%
|
| NL | 2009 | 6. | LAD | RF | Andre Ethier | 20%
|
| NL | 2003 | 9. | CHC | SP | Mark Prior | 20%
|
| NL | 2020 | 8. | SFG | LF | Mike Yastrzemski | 20%
|
| AL | 2005 | 5. | CLE | DH | Travis Hafner | 20%
|
| AL | 2006 | 8. | CLE | DH | Travis Hafner | 20%
|
| NL | 2014 | 9. | PIT | 3B | Josh Harrison | 18%
|
| NL | 2011 | 4. | ARI | LF | Justin Upton | 18%
|
| AL | 2007 | 5. | BOS | 3B | Mike Lowell | 18%
|
| NL | 2005 | 7. | PHI | LF | Pat Burrell | 18%
|
| NL | 2010 | 7. | SFG | 1B | Aubrey Huff | 13%
|
| NL | 2005 | 9. | SDP | LF | Brian Giles | 13%
|
| NL | 2010 | 9. | ATL | 2B | Martin Prado | 13%
|
| NL | 2008 | 8. | PHI | RP | Brad Lidge | 11%
|
| AL | 2009 | 7. | BOS | LF | Jason Bay | 11%
|
| NL | 2004 | 6. | ATL | RF | JD Drew | 11%
|
| AL | 2009 | 5. | LAA | 1B | Kendrys Morales | 11%
|
| NL | 2005 | 4. | HOU | 3B | Morgan Ensberg | 11%
|
| AL | 2008 | 5. | CHW | LF | Carlos Quentin | 9%
|
| AL | 2009 | 10. | LAA | 3B | Chone Figgins | 9%
|
| NL | 2004 | 9. | SDP | 2B | Mark Loretta | 9%
|
| AL | 2003 | 4. | TOR/MIN | LF | Shannon Stewart | 9%
|
| AL | 2006 | 10. | DET | SS | Carlos Guillen | 7%
|