| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Edward Nigma | The Riddler | 100%
|
| Selina Kyle | Catwoman | 96%
|
| Jack Napier | The Joker | 96%
|
| Oswald Cobblepott | The Penguin | 96%
|
| Harvey Dent | Two-Face | 96%
|
| Harleen Quinzel | Harley Quinn | 93%
|
| Pamela Isley | Poison Ivy | 93%
|
| Victor Fries | Mr. Freeze | 89%
|
| Jonathan Crane | Scarecrow | 89%
|
| Waylon Jones | Killer Croc | 85%
|
| Unknown | Bane | 81%
|
| Slade Wilson | Deathstroke | 78%
|
| Kirk Langstrom | Man Bat | 78%
|
| Roman Sionis | Black Mask | 67%
|
| Floyd Lawton | Deadshot | 67%
|
| Jervis Tetch | Mad Hatter | 67%
|
| League of Assassins | Ra's Al Ghūl | 67%
|
| Matt Hagan | Clayface | 63%
|
| Garfield Lynns | Firefly | 63%
|
| Julian Day | Calendar Man | 56%
|
| Victor Zsasz | Zsasz | 52%
|
| Thomas Elliott | Hush | 48%
|
| Mitchell Mayo | Condiment King | 41%
|
| Lazlo Valentin | Professor Pyg | 37%
|
| Arnold Wesker | Ventriloquist | 30%
|
| Maximillian Zeus | Maxie Zeus | 22%
|
| Lonnie Machin | Anarky | 19%
|
| Lester Buchinsky | Electrocutioner | 19%
|
| Anatoli Knyazev | KGBeast | 19%
|
| Otis Flannegan | Ratcatcher | 19%
|
| William Cobb | Talon | 19%
|
| Michael Lane | Azrael | 15%
|
| Eric Needham | Black Spider | 7%
|
| Mark Desmond | Blockbuster | 7%
|
| Peter Merkel | Rag Doll | 7%
|