| Times won | Team they won with | Year Span | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | Yankees (11) | 2017 - 2025 | Aaron Judge | 100%
|
| 13 | Giants (9) Pirates (4) | 1990 - 2004 | Barry Bonds | 100%
|
| 7 | Cardinals (6) Angels (1) | 2003 - 2015 | Albert Pujols | 75%
|
| 10 | Mariners (1) Rangers (3)Yankees (6) | 1996 - 2010 | Alex Rodriguez | 75%
|
| 5 | Pirates (5) | 2012 - 2017 | Andrew McCutchen | 75%
|
| 4 | Phillies (2) Nationals (2) | 2015 - 2024 | Bryce Harper | 75%
|
| 6 | Braves (6) | 1980 - 1986 | Dale Murphy | 75%
|
| 8 | White Sox (8) | 1991 - 1997 | Frank Thomas | 75%
|
| 6 | Royals (6) | 1980 - 1990 | George Brett | 75%
|
| 6 | Tigers (6) | 2008 - 2016 | Miguel Cabrera | 75%
|
| 5 | Angels (5) | 2012 - 2018 | Mike Trout | 75%
|
| 6 | Angels (4) Dodgers (2) | 2021 - 2025 | Shohei Ohtani | 75%
|
| 4 | Cardinals (3) Rockies (1) | 2015 - 2022 | Nolan Arenado | 50%
|
| 6 | Reds (6) | 1965 - 1979 | Pete Rose | 50%
|
| 4 | Braves (4) | 2021 - 2023 | Ronald Acuña Jr. | 50%
|
| 6 | Reds (6) | 1976 - 1979 | George Foster | 25%
|
| 6 | Athletics (2) Yankees (4) | 2002 - 2006 | Jason Giambi | 25%
|