| # | Title | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | Jeff The Killer | 94%
|
| 8 | Left Right Game Pt.1 | 94%
|
| 9 | Left Right Game Pt.2 | 94%
|
| 4 | Borrasca Pt.1 | 88%
|
| 5 | Borrasca Pt.2 | 88%
|
| 51 | Borrasca V | 88%
|
| 5 | Marble Hornets Pt. 1 | 88%
|
| 6 | Marble Hornets Pt. 2 | 88%
|
| 7 | Penpal | 88%
|
| 1 | The Stairs In The Woods | 88%
|
| 15 | Creepy Grab Bag #1 | 82%
|
| 25 | My Husband Has Taken Our Roleplaying Too Far | 82%
|
| 3 | The Russian Sleep Experiment | 82%
|
| 16 | Tommy Taffy | 71%
|
| 20 | Creepy Grab Bag #2 | 65%
|
| 19 | Feed The Pig | 65%
|
| 57 | Mother Horse Eyes | 65%
|
| 6 | My Dead Girlfriend Keeps Messaging Me on Facebook | 65%
|
| 14 | NoEnd House | 65%
|
| 18 | Psychosis | 65%
|
| 13 | The Showers | 65%
|
| 12 | 1999 | 59%
|
| 27 | Deepwoods | 59%
|
| 1 | GREYLOCK | 59%
|
| 3 | Midwest Angelica | 59%
|
| 48 | Spire In The Woods | 59%
|
| 21 | Stolen Tongues | 59%
|
| 29 | Ted The Caver | 59%
|
| 61 | The Church In The Woods | 59%
|
| 31 | The Dionaea House | 59%
|
| 11 | The Thing In The Basement Is Getting Better At Mimicking People | 59%
|
| 4 | UrbanSPOOK | 59%
|
| 43 | Dagon's Mirror | 53%
|
| 36 | I Dared My Best Friend To Ruin My Life | 53%
|
| 24 | Tales From The Gas Station | 53%
|
| 10 | Gr3gory88 | 47%
|
| 37 | I'm Blind, I'm Not Sure How Many Steps My Staircase Has | 47%
|
| 52 | The Sun Vanished | 47%
|
| 35 | Berries In The Window | 41%
|
| 42 | Creepypasta Classics: The Rake, Candle Cove, Mr. Widemouth | 41%
|
| 55 | My Sugar Daddy Asks Me For Weird Favors | 41%
|
| 41 | Azalea's Cookhouse | 35%
|
| 47 | Burgrr Entries | 35%
|
| 50 | Greywater | 35%
|
| 33 | If You're Armed At the Glenmont Metro, Please Shoot Me | 35%
|
| 44 | I Pretended to Be A Missing Girl | 35%
|
| 22 | It Breathes, It Bleeds, It Breeds | 35%
|
| 56 | I Work At A Half-Priced Voodoo Shop | 35%
|
| 40 | My crew And I Are Stuck Aboard An Abandoned Ship | 35%
|
| 23 | My Job Is Watching A Woman Trapped In A Room | 35%
|
| 39 | The Hidden Webpage | 35%
|
| 46 | The Red Tower | 35%
|
| 49 | Ticci Toby | 35%
|
| 2 | USERNAME 666 | 35%
|
| 54 | Ensorcelled in the Earth | 29%
|
| 32 | I'm A Cop & I Keep Getting Called To The Same House | 29%
|
| 26 | My Dog Was Missing For Three Days | 29%
|
| 17 | My Wife's Been Peeking At Me From Around Corners | 29%
|
| 65 | The Dead Girl In My Yard | 29%
|
| 30 | The Whistler At 3:03 AM | 29%
|
| 53 | Camp Oakwood | 24%
|
| 60 | Fleshgait | 24%
|
| 45 | I Wrote Myself A Letter, I Got A Response | 24%
|
| 28 | SCP 3000 | 24%
|
| 62 | The Ocean Is Much Deeper Than We Thought | 24%
|
| 34 | The Only Other Astronaut On This Mission Died Six Weeks Ago | 24%
|
| 63 | I Clean Hoarder Houses For A Living | 18%
|
| 59 | It Came From A Fan... | 18%
|
| 64 | My Little Pony Creepypasta... | 18%
|
| 38 | The Pigeons Around Here Aren't Real | 18%
|
| 58 | We Weren't Allowed To Talk To Women | 12%
|