| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Cake Loving Cat | Stampy | 100%
|
| Blue Wolf. Known for being salty | AntAntixx | 90%
|
| Beware headphone users of this enderman! | MCA39 | 90%
|
| Old Foxy Fox | MiniGod951 | 90%
|
| Panda girl | PaigeThePanda | 90%
|
| Purple and white knight, skull masters leader | Spike Woody | 90%
|
| Wears a tuxedo, king of puns and twinkie lord | TankMattXBL | 90%
|
| Cookie Man | BigBstatz | 80%
|
| The panther in the MM crew | Dynamic Barton | 80%
|
| Llama loving Ocelot | ibxtoycat | 80%
|
| Irish Elf | ImScottJones | 80%
|
| Blue frog | Jake Globox | 80%
|
| Nocturnal Fox | MrNightfoxx | 80%
|
| Red and Yellow Birdy. "It's not me!" | PHO3N1X | 80%
|
| Penguin who loves modding and fish! | SB737 | 80%
|
| Stampy's slippery sidekick | Squid | 80%
|
| Leprechaun, also a train sound | ChooChoosGaming | 70%
|
| Flower girl, once of the Blocksmiths | MelmoLuvsYou | 70%
|
| Crocodile - part of the 4 vs 4J team | Eckosoldier | 50%
|
| Stampy's feathery companion | Squaishey | 50%
|
| Wolf Man | Drake Softpaw | 30%
|