| Record | Team(s) | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| 27-13 (.675) | New York Yankees | 90%
|
| 2-0 (1.000) | Miami Marlins / Toronto Blue Jays | 86%
|
| 1-0 (1.000) | Arizona Diamondbacks / Los Angeles Angels | 69%
|
| 11-8 (.579) | St. Louis Cardinals | 68%
|
| 0-0 (.000) | Seattle Mariners / Washington Nationals | 67%
|
| 0-1 (.000) | Colorado Rockies / Milwaukee Brewers / Tampa Bay Rays | 63%
|
| 0-2 (.000) | San Diego Padres / Texas Rangers | 63%
|
| 9-4 (.692) | Boston Red Sox | 53%
|
| 6-14 (.300) | Los Angeles Dodgers | 51%
|
| 9-5 (.643) | Oakland Athletics | 51%
|
| 8-12 (.400) | San Francisco Giants | 46%
|
| 7-2 (.714) | Pittsburgh Pirates | 44%
|
| 2-3 (.400) | New York Mets | 42%
|
| 3-14 (.176) | Chicago Cubs | 41%
|
| 5-4 (.556) | Cincinnati Reds | 41%
|
| 4-7 (.364) | Detroit Tigers | 39%
|
| 3-6 (.333) | Atlanta Braves | 38%
|
| 1-1 (.500) | Houston Astros | 38%
|
| 2-5 (.286) | Philadelphia Phillies | 36%
|
| 2-2 (.500) | Kansas City Royals | 34%
|
| 2-4 (.333) | Cleveland Indians | 32%
|
| 3-3 (.500) | Minnesota Twins | 32%
|
| 3-4 (.429) | Baltimore Orioles | 28%
|
| 3-2 (.600) | Chicago White Sox | 27%
|