| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Dodgers (2008-2025) | Clayton Kershaw (3052) | 96%
|
| Angels (1966-1993) | Nolan Ryan (5714) | 96%
|
| Braves (1986-2008) | Greg Maddux (3371) | 92%
|
| Astros (2005-Present) | Justin Verlander (3553)* | 92%
|
| Diamondbacks (1988-2009) | Randy Johnson (4875) | 92%
|
| Mets (1967-1986) | Tom Seaver (3640) | 92%
|
| Red Sox (1984-2007) | Roger Clemens (4672) | 88%
|
| Twins (1907-1927) | Walter Johnson (3509) | 88%
|
| Braves (1988-2009) | John Smoltz (3084) | 84%
|
| Red Sox (1992-2009) | Pedro Martinez (3154) | 84%
|
| Nationals (2008-Present) | Max Scherzer (3489)* | 80%
|
| Phillies (1965-1988) | Steve Carlton (4136) | 72%
|
| Cardinals (1959-1975) | Bob Gibson (3117) | 64%
|
| Yankees (2001-2019) | CC Sabathia (3093) | 56%
|
| Phillies (1988-2007) | Curt Schilling (3116) | 52%
|
| Red Sox (1890-1911) | Cy Young (2803) | 52%
|
| Royals (2004-2023) | Zach Greinke (2979) | 52%
|
| Giants (1962-1983) | Gaylord Perry (3534) | 48%
|
| Orioles (1991-2008) | Mike Mussina (2813) | 48%
|
| Braves (1964-1987) | Phil Niekro (3342) | 48%
|
| Dodgers (1966-1988) | Don Sutton (3574) | 40%
|
| Cubs (1965-1983) | Fergie Jenkins (3192) | 40%
|
| Twins (1970-1992) | Bert Blyleven (3701) | 36%
|
| Phillies (1955-1971) | Jim Bunning (2855) | 20%
|
| Tigers (1963-1979) | Mickey Lolich (2832) | 20%
|