| Team | Position | Name | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yankees | LF | Babe Ruth | 96%
|
| Diamondbacks | P | Randy Johnson | 96%
|
| Orioles | SS | Cal Ripken Jr. | 89%
|
| Mariners | CF | Ken Griffey Jr. | 89%
|
| Braves | RF | Hank Aaron | 85%
|
| Angels | CF | Mike Trout | 85%
|
| Padres | RF | Tony Gwynn | 85%
|
| Twins/Senators | P | Walter Johnson | 85%
|
| Giants | CF | Willie Mays | 85%
|
| Dodgers | P | Sandy Koufax | 81%
|
| White Sox | 1B/DH | Frank Thomas | 78%
|
| Royals | 3B | George Brett | 78%
|
| Rangers | C | Ivan Rodriguez | 78%
|
| Astros | P | Nolan Ryan | 78%
|
| Athletics | LF | Rickey Henderson | 78%
|
| Phillies | 3B | Mike Schmidt | 74%
|
| Reds | IF/OF | Pete Rose | 74%
|
| Pirates | RF | Roberto Clemente | 74%
|
| Red Sox | LF | Ted Williams | 74%
|
| Tigers | CF | Ty Cobb | 74%
|
| Cubs | SS | Ernie Banks | 70%
|
| Brewers | SS/CF | Robin Yount | 70%
|
| Rockies | 1B | Todd Helton | 70%
|
| Rays | 3B | Evan Longoria | 67%
|
| Mets | P | Tom Seaver | 67%
|
| Marlins | OF | Giancarlo Stanton | 59%
|
| Cardinals | OF | Stan Musial | 59%
|
| Nationals/Expos | P | Max Scherzer | 52%
|
| Blue Jays | P | Roy Halladay | 52%
|
| Guardians/Indians | P | Bob Feller | 41%
|