| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Shoeless | Joe Jackson | 82%
|
| Rapid Robert | Bob Feller | 66%
|
| Pronk | Travis Hafner | 57%
|
| Sudden Sam | Sam McDowell | 46%
|
| Black Jack | Jack McDowell | 45%
|
| Mr. Freeze or Joey | Albert Belle | 44%
|
| The Human Rain Delay or Grover | Mike Hargrove | 43%
|
| Mudcat | Jim Grant | 34%
|
| Little 'O' | Omar Vizquel | 34%
|
| Archie | Rick Manning | 33%
|
| Gonzo or Igor | Juan Gonzalez | 29%
|
| Jonesey | Doug Jones | 28%
|
| Bulldog | Orel Hershiser | 21%
|
| Candi Man | Candy Maldonado | 18%
|
| Macho Man | Ernie Camacho | 8%
|