| Year | Losing Team | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1993 | Phillies | Joe Carter | 50%
|
| 2007 | Rockies | Seth Smith | 50%
|
| 1995 | Indians | Carlos Baerga | 38%
|
| 2011 | Rangers | David Murphy | 38%
|
| 2004 | Cardinals | Édgar Rentería | 38%
|
| 1997 | Indians | Édgar Rentería | 38%
|
| 2001 | Yankees | Luis Gonzalez | 38%
|
| 1996 | Braves | Mark Lemke | 38%
|
| 2016 | Indians | Michael Martínez | 38%
|
| 2000 | Mets | Mike Piazza | 38%
|
| 2022 | Phillies | Nick Castellanos | 38%
|
| 2017 | Dodgers | Corey Seager | 25%
|
| 2003 | Yankees | Jorge Posada | 25%
|
| 2002 | Giants | Kenny Lofton | 25%
|
| 2018 | Dodgers | Manny Machado | 25%
|
| 2019 | Astros | Michael Brantley | 25%
|
| 2012 | Tigers | Miguel Cabrera | 25%
|
| 2014 | Royals | Salvador Pérez | 25%
|
| 2015 | Mets | Wilmer Flores | 25%
|
| 1999 | Braves | Keith Lockhart | 13%
|
| 2013 | Cardinals | Matt Carpenter | 13%
|
| 2010 | Rangers | Nelson Cruz | 13%
|
| 2009 | Phillies | Shane Victorino | 13%
|
| 2020 | Rays | Willy Adames | 13%
|
| 2021 | Astros | Yuli Gurriel | 13%
|
| 2006 | Tigers | Brandon Inge | 0%
|
| 2008 | Rays | Eric Hinske | 0%
|
| 1998 | Padres | Mark Sweeney | 0%
|
| 2005 | Astros | Orlando Palmeiro | 0%
|