| Year | Winning Team | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 94%
|
| 2001 | Diamondbacks | Mariano Rivera | 94%
|
| 2000 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 94%
|
| 1999 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 94%
|
| 1998 | Yankees | Mariano Rivera | 94%
|
| 2014 | Giants | Madison Bumgarner | 65%
|
| 2018 | Red Sox | Chris Sale | 53%
|
| 2020 | Dodgers | Julio Urías | 41%
|
| 1996 | Yankees | John Wetteland | 35%
|
| 1993 | Blue Jays | Mitch Williams | 35%
|
| 2022 | Astros | Ryan Pressly | 35%
|
| 2006 | Cardinals | Adam Wainwright | 29%
|
| 2007 | Red Sox | Jonathan Papelbon | 29%
|
| 2004 | Red Sox | Keith Foulke | 29%
|
| 2012 | Giants | Sergio Romo | 29%
|
| 2010 | Giants | Brian Wilson | 24%
|
| 1997 | Marlins | Charles Nagy | 24%
|
| 2017 | Astros | Charlie Morton | 24%
|
| 2003 | Marlins | Josh Beckett | 24%
|
| 1995 | Braves | Mark Wohlers | 24%
|
| 2002 | Angels | Troy Percival | 24%
|
| 2021 | Braves | Will Smith | 24%
|
| 2008 | Phillies | Brad Lidge | 18%
|
| 2019 | Nationals | Daniel Hudson | 18%
|
| 2013 | Red Sox | Koji Uehara | 18%
|
| 2016 | Cubs | Mike Montgomery | 18%
|
| 2015 | Royals | Wade Davis | 18%
|
| 2005 | White Sox | Bobby Jenks | 12%
|
| 2011 | Cardinals | Jason Motte | 6%
|