| Peak Rank | Song Title | Lyrical Hint | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Sweet Caroline | Good times never seemed so good | 100%
|
| 1 | You Don't Bring Me Flowers | You don't sing me love songs | 80%
|
| 1 | Song Sung Blue | Everybody knows one | 76%
|
| 20 | Forever in Blue Jeans | Money talks / But it don't sing and dance / And it don't walk | 68%
|
| 11 | Play Me | You are the words / I am the tune | 66%
|
| 8 | America | Free / Only want to be free | 64%
|
| 4 | I Am ... I Said | And I am lost and I can't even say why | 64%
|
| 6 | Cherry, Cherry | She got the way to move me | 62%
|
| 2 | Love on the Rocks | Pour me a drink / And I'll tell you some lies | 58%
|
| 22 | Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show | Pack up the babies / Grab the old ladies | 50%
|
| 1 | Cracklin' Rosie | She got the way to make me happy | 50%
|
| 10 | Girl, You'll Be a Woman Soon | Soon, you'll need a man | 50%
|
| 6 | Hello Again | Just called to let you know / I think about you every night | 42%
|
| 21 | Solitary Man | I'll be what I am | 40%
|
| 17 | September Morn' | Two lovers playing scenes from some romantic play | 38%
|
| 22 | Kentucky Woman | She shines with her own kind of light | 34%
|
| 6 | Holly Holy | And she comes / And I run just like the wind will | 28%
|
| 20 | He Ain't Heavy...He's My Brother | And the load / Doesn't weigh me down at all | 26%
|
| 11 | Yesterday's Songs | Yesterday's words / Don't make themselves heard | 26%
|
| 5 | Longfellow Serenade | For she was a lady / And I was a dreamer | 24%
|
| 24 | Shilo | I wanted to fly / She made me feel like I could | 24%
|
| 11 | If You Know What I Mean | It was another time / It was another place | 20%
|
| 13 | Thank the Lord for the Night Time | Daytime turns me off, and I don't mean maybe | 20%
|
| 16 | Desiree | There I was found / By the sweet passion found | 18%
|
| 18 | You Got to Me | You got to my soul / You got control | 14%
|
| 14 | Stones/Crunchy Granola Suite | Drop your shrink and stop your drinkin' | 12%
|
| 16 | I Got the Feelin' (Oh No No) | Don't have to say it / It's there in your eyes | 4%
|
| 17 | Walk on Water | She leads the children | 4%
|