| Hint | Character | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|
| B | King of the Koopas | Bowser | 98%
|
| D | Large, stubborn ape | Donkey Kong | 98%
|
| L | Number 2 plumber | Luigi | 98%
|
| M | Its-a him! | Mario | 97%
|
| P | Princess of the Mushroom Kingdom | Peach | 97%
|
| G | Usually the first enemy Mario encounters | Goomba | 94%
|
| Y | Mario's trusty dinosaur steed | Yoshi | 93%
|
| C | Common fish enemies | Cheep Cheep | 92%
|
| S | Few have ever seen what's underneath their mask... | Shy Guy | 92%
|
| R | Guardian of the Lumas | Rosalina | 91%
|
| H | Hammer-throwing soldiers and source of rage for many | Hammer Bro. | 90%
|
| W | Garlic-loving doppelganger | Wario | 90%
|
| T | Mushroom Kingdom denizen | Toad | 85%
|
| K | Bowser's loyal attendant | Kamek | 82%
|
| N | Carries around a sack filled with power-ups he's "collected" | Nabbit | 79%
|
| I | Near-sighted Koopaling | Iggy | 78%
|
| E | Inventor and retired ghost hunter | E. Gadd | 75%
|
| A | Desert sky inhabitant with a temper | Angry Sun | 56%
|
| F | Reoccurring antagonist of the Mario & Luigi series | Fawful | 54%
|
| Z | Undead Shy Guy | Zombie Guy | 48%
|
| U | Cheeky, hat-stealing monkey | Ukiki | 46%
|
| V | One of the Shadow Sirens | Vivian | 43%
|
| Q | Queen of the Bean-Bean Kingdom | Queen {Bean} | 39%
|
| X | Organization lead by Grodus that seeks to ressurect the Shadow Queen | X-Naut | 32%
|
| J | Dance-loving employee of WarioWare, Inc. | Jimmy T | 30%
|
| O | Flower Kingdom menaces that kick whatever comes their way | Outmaway | 23%
|