| Character | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Tate Langdon, Kit Walker, Kyle Spencer, Jimmy Darling, James March, Edward Phillipe Mott, Rory Monahan, Kai Anderson | Evan Peters | 98%
|
| Billie Dean Howard, Lana Winters, Cordelia Foxx, Bette & Dot Tattler, Sally McKenna, Audrey Tindall/Shelby Miller, Ally Mayfair-Richards | Sarah Paulson | 95%
|
| Madison Montgomery, Maggie Esmeralda, Serena Belinda | Emma Roberts | 90%
|
| Constance Langdon, Sister Jude Martin, Fiona Goode, Elsa Mars | Jessica Lange | 90%
|
| The Countess, Scathach | Lady Gaga | 90%
|
| Marie Delphine LaLaurie, Ethel Darling, Iris, The Butcher/Agnes Mary Winstead | Kathy Bates | 81%
|
| Violet Harmon, Zoe Benson, Sophie Green | Taissa Farmiga | 81%
|
| Nora Montgomery, Sister Mary Eunice McKee, Misty Day, Aileen Wuornos, Shelby Miller | Lily Rabe | 80%
|
| Marie Laveau, Desiree Dupree, Ramona Royale, Lee Harris/Monet Tumusiime | Angela Bassett | 70%
|
| Larry Harvey, Spalding, Stanley, Liz Taylor, Dr. Elias Cunningham | Denis O'Hare | 64%
|
| Moira O'Hara, The Angel of Death, Myrtle Snow, Gloria Mott, Mama Polk, Bebe Babbitt | Frances Conroy | 57%
|
| Will Drake, Sidney Aaron James, Dr. Rudy Vincent | Cheyenne Jackson | 47%
|