| Nominated By | Year | Result | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ronald Reagan | 1987 | Rejected by Senate | Robert Bork | 79%
|
| Barack Obama | 2016 | Senate Inaction | Merrick Garland | 74%
|
| George W Bush | 2005 | Withdrawn | Harriet Miers | 42%
|
| Andrew Jackson | 1837 | Candidate Declined | William Smith | 26%
|
| Grover Cleveland | 1894 | Rejected by Senate | Wheeler Hazard Peckham | 11%
|
| Grover Cleveland | 1893 | Rejected by Senate | William B Hornblower | 11%
|
| Richard Nixon | 1969 | Rejected by Senate | Clement Haynsworth | 5%
|
| Chester Arthur | 1882 | Candidate Declined | George F Edmunds | 5%
|
| Ulysses S Grant | 1873 | Senate Judicial Committee failure, withdrawn | George Henry Williams | 5%
|
| Richard Nixon | 1970 | Rejected by Senate | G Harrold Carswell | 5%
|
| Lyndon Johnson | 1968 | Nullified due to vacancy not appearing | Homer Thornberry | 5%
|
| Herbert Hoover | 1930 | Rejected by Senate | John J Parker | 5%
|
| James Madison | 1811 | Candidate Declined | John Quincy Adams | 5%
|
| James Madison | 1811 | Candidate Declined | Levi Lincoln, Sr. | 5%
|
| George Washington | 1789 | Candidate Declined | Robert H Harrison | 5%
|
| Chester Arthur | 1882 | Candidate Declined | Roscoe Conkling | 5%
|
| James Madison | 1811 | Rejected by Senate | Alexander Wolcott | 0%
|
| Ulysses S Grant | 1874 | Withdrawn | Caleb Cushing | 0%
|
| Ulysses S Grant | 1869 | Rejected by Senate | Ebenezer R Hoar | 0%
|
| Millard Fillmore | 1852 | Senate Inaction | Edward A Bradford | 0%
|
| John Tyler | 1845 | Senate Postponed, Withdrawn | Edward King | 0%
|
| Ulysses S Grant | 1869 | Died before Confirmation | Edwin Stanton | 0%
|
| Millard Fillmore | 1853 | Senate Inaction | George E Badger | 0%
|
| James Polk | 1845 | Rejected by Senate | George W Woodward | 0%
|
| Andrew Johnson | 1866 | Nullified due to reduction of seats | Henry Stanbery | 0%
|
| James Polk | 1844 | Candidate Declined | James Buchanan | 0%
|
| James Buchanan | 1861 | Rejected by Senate | Jeremiah S Black | 0%
|
| John Tyler | 1844 | Rejected by Senate | John C Spencer | 0%
|
| John Quincy Adams | 1828 | Senate Postponed | John J Crittenden | 0%
|
| John Tyler | 1845 | Senate Inaction | John M Read | 0%
|
| John Tyler | 1844 | Senate Postponed, Withdrawn | Reuben H Walworth | 0%
|
| Millard Fillmore | 1853 | Senate Inaction | William C Micou | 0%
|