Broadway Musical Characters: Spot the Imposter

Which character is NOT in each of these shows? Click on the one that doesn't belong.
Quiz by
jwjh
Rate:
Last updated: May 15, 2026
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedMay 15, 2026
Times taken6
Average score60.0%
Report this quizReport
4:00
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
1. Once Upon a Mattress
Far from spewing balderdash, King Sextimus in Once Upon a Mattress is silent for almost the entire show.
King Balderdash
Princess Winifred
Queen Aggravain
Prince Dauntless
2. West Side Story
There are lots of Fernandos out there, but not in West Side Story.
Fernando
Action
Chino
Diesel
3. Hadestown
In Hadestown, the life of the party is Persephone.
Dionysus
Hades
Hermes
Eurydice
4. Into the Woods
Into the Woods interweaves many famous fairy tales, but not Hansel and Gretel.
Hansel and Gretel
Rapunzel
The Baker and The Baker's Wife
Cinderella
5. MJ The Musical
Reggie Jackson was a legendary baseball player.
Michael Jackson
Joe Jackson
Randy Jackson
Reggie Jackson
6. Guys and Dolls
Lt Schrank is a character in West Side Story.
Nicely-Nicely Johnson
Big Jule
Sgt. Sarah Brown
Lt. Schrank
7. The Music Man
Agnes Gooch is a character in the Jerry Herman musical Mame, from the same era.
Agnes Gooch
Marcellus Washburn
Harold Hill
Winthrop Paroo
8. Little Shop of Horrors
Like the Ronettes, the Crystals, and the Chiffons, the Shirelles were also a '60s girl group, but not one of the Little Shop "urchins".
Chiffon
Crystal
Ronette
Shirelle
9. Grease
Potsie is a character on TV's Happy Days (not to be confused with Putzie, a minor character only in the movie version of Grease)
Frenchie
Doodie
Potsie
Kenickie
10. A Strange Loop
Tevin Campbell is an R&B singer, songwriter, and musician. Tyler Perry is a recurring character portrayed in a satirical light. The main character, Usher, has no relationship to the R&B singer of the same name.
Inwood Daddy
Tyler Perry
Usher
Tevin Campbell
11. Rent
Rainbow Johnson is a character on TV's "black-ish"
Rainbow Johnson
Benny Coffin
Tom Collins
Mimi Márquez
12. Avenue Q
Crazy Harry is a Jim Henson Muppet. Christmas Eve is one of the main human characters, originally played by Ann Harada. "Gary Coleman" is a major character, usually played very loosely by a woman.
Christmas Eve
Trekkie Monster
Crazy Harry
Gary Coleman
13. Ragtime
One of the three featured families in Ragtime is only ever known by their generic familial names. Grandmother is not one of them. (Technically, Mother is also Older Sister, though never referred to as such.)
Father
Younger Brother
Mother
Grandmother
14. Hamilton
Many revolutionary-era American figures are portrayed in Hamilton, but not Ben.
George Washington
Ben Franklin
James Madison
Thomas Jefferson
15. Fiddler on the Roof
Yentl the title character of a 1983 musical movie, played by Barbra Streisand.
Yentl
Motel
Hodel
Tzietel
Save Your Stats
Your Next Quiz
Name all 50 states in the USA. Easy, right?
The most intellectual quiz to ever appear on JetPunk.
Try to guess the most common given names for men currently alive in the United States.
Drag the flag onto the correct country. Careful, though! One wrong move and the game ends.
Comments
No comments yet