| Antagonist | Musical | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Jafar | Aladdin | 97%
|
| Gaston | Beauty and the Beast | 97%
|
| Aaron Burr | Hamilton | 97%
|
| The Wizard | Wicked | 97%
|
| Miss Hannigan | Annie | 91%
|
| Javert | Les Miserables | 91%
|
| Agatha Trunchbull | Matilda | 91%
|
| Audrey II | Little Shop of Horrors | 88%
|
| Jud Fry | Oklahoma! | 53%
|
| General Butt F*ing Naked | The Book of Mormon | 53%
|
| Bernardo | West Side Story | 50%
|
| Judge Turpin | Sweeney Todd | 47%
|
| Caldwell B. Cladwell | Urinetown | 44%
|
| Benny Coffin III | Rent | 34%
|
| Anatole/Helene | Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 | 31%
|
| Bud Frump | How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying | 28%
|
| Commissar Thuy | Miss Saigon | 28%
|
| Fastrada/Leading Player | Pippin | 28%
|
| Gabe Goodman | Next to Normal | 25%
|
| St. Jimmy | American Idiot | 22%
|
| Carl-Magnus Malcolm | A Little Night Music | 16%
|
| Harry Beaton | Brigadoon | 16%
|
| Bob Sheldon | The Outsiders | 16%
|
| Mr. Applegate | Damn Yankees | 13%
|
| Tommy Gnosis | Hedwig and the Angry Inch | 9%
|