Broadway Musicals: Spot the Wrong Song

It's a show set largely in the underworld, but there's no song by that name.

"Something Wonderful" is from THE KING AND I. If you didn't pick it, you may be thinking of "Something Good," which was written for THE SOUND OF MUSIC movie. Also, this "Maria" is not to be confused with "Maria" from WEST SIDE STORY.

"A Sweet Little Bullet from a Pretty Blue Gun" is a Tom Waits song. To be fair, many of his songs are set in worlds not unlike the world of CHICAGO.

Rapunzel is a character in the show, and there is much talking and singing about her hair, but there is no such song.

Nothing in JCS by that name, but "Golgotha" is the title of several different Christian rock/pop songs, by bands including W.A.S.P., Hardknock, and With Blood Comes Cleansing

"Shame in My Body" is from the off-Broadway musical TEETH, co-written by A STRANGE LOOP writer Michael R. Jackson

"Give Them What They Want" is in the musical of DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS. (Also, the central scheme in THE PRODUCERS is to put on a terrible show that flops - in other words, what the people DON'T want.)

"Make Them Hear You" is in RAGTIME.

"People Will Say We're in Love" is from OKLAHOMA. There is a similar song in CAROUSEL called "If I Loved You." The "almost in love" song is a staple of classic musical theater.

"I Got the Sun in the Morning" is from Irving Berlin's ANNIE GET YOUR GUN.

The XYZ Affair did happen during this time period, but it's only obliquely referenced in HAMILTON

Although it's the topic of the show, there's no song simply called "Dancing". There is one in HELLO, DOLLY

"I Can't Do It Alone" is from CHICAGO.

It's certainly something Elphaba would want, but not the title of any song she sings.

"The Lonely Jew on Christmas" is from the first season of SOUTH PARK. Its creators would soon collaborate with AVENUE Q co-writer Bobby Lopez on THE BOOK OF MORMON.