| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Known for his one-handed catch. | Odell Beckham Jr. | 98%
|
| QB who beat Tom Brady twice in the Super Bowl. | Eli Manning | 86%
|
| Megatron | Calvin Johnson | 81%
|
| Player famous for his 2024 backwards hurdle. | Saquon Barkley | 81%
|
| QB who got injured immediately after running out with the American flag on the Jets. | Aaron Rodgers | 76%
|
| 2025 rookie known to stand straight up in the backfield. | Ashton Jeanty | 76%
|
| Player who appeared on the Madden 20 cover. | Patrick Mahomes | 76%
|
| QB who filled in for injured Bo Nix in the 2026 AFC championship. | Jarrett Stidham | 74%
|
| Player known for his iconic picture staring at the Chiefs' celebration confetti in the AFC championship. | Stefon Diggs | 74%
|
| "I call him 9". | JJ McCarthy | 71%
|
| Player with the nickname "Knuckles" in the "Sonic and Knuckles" backfield duo. | David Montgomery | 69%
|
| Backup QB who gives the funniest interviews and stole crab legs. | Jameis Winston | 67%
|
| Quarterback famous for being terrible in cold weather. | Tua Tagovailoa | 67%
|
| Former Arizona St running back known for running straight into people. | Cam Skattebo | 64%
|
| Defensive player who was fined for spitting on Dak Prescott. | Jalen Carter | 64%
|
| Tight end who fantasy managers swear is his breakout year every year. | Kyle Pitts | 62%
|
| QB who released the song "Perfect Timing" | Shedeur Sanders | 62%
|
| Eagles O-Lineman who released a Christmas album (3 options) | Lane Johnson, Jordan Mailata, Jason Kelce | 60%
|
| Scored 6 TDs on Christmas Day 2020. | Alvin Kamara | 57%
|
| Former teammate of the above player who disappeared after a record-breaking 2019. | Michael Thomas | 55%
|
| Italian backup QB known for his mafia-looking agent.. | Tommy DeVito | 55%
|
| "Throw it on a dime, like I ain't even trying, Just a kid from Briar Woods I'm wearing number 9". | Trace McSorley | 40%
|
| Hypothetical MVP every year but never won it. | Justin Herbert | 31%
|