| Nickname(s) | President | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The Peanut Farmer | Jimmy Carter | 97%
|
| The Great Emancipator | Abraham Lincoln | 92%
|
| That Man in the White House | Franklin D. Roosevelt | 92%
|
| Dubya | George Bush the Younger | 92%
|
| Tricky Dick | Richard Nixon | 92%
|
| TR, the Hero of San Juan | Teddy Roosevelt | 92%
|
| Unconditional Surrender Grant | Ulysses S. Grant | 92%
|
| The Hero of New Orleans, Old Hickory | Andrew Jackson | 87%
|
| The American Cincinnatus, the Father of His Country | George Washington | 87%
|
| The Sage of Monticello | Thomas Jefferson | 84%
|
| Silent Cal | Calvin Coolidge | 79%
|
| His Accidency | John Tyler | 79%
|
| Old Tippecanoe | William Henry Harrison | 76%
|
| The First Black President, Slick Willie | Bill Clinton | 74%
|
| Dutch, the Gipper | Ronald Reagan | 74%
|
| His Little Majesty | James Madison | 61%
|
| Dr. President | Woodrow Wilson | 61%
|
| The Amtrak President | Joe Biden | 53%
|
| The Old Public Functionary, Ten-Cent Jimmy | James Buchanan | 47%
|
| Hono(u)rable mention: British PM nicknamed "God's Only Mistake" | William Gladstone | 8%
|