| Rank (seed) | Record | NFL Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| AFC North Champ (2) | 12-4 | Pittsburgh Steelers | 95%
|
| AFC South Champ (1) | 13-3 | Tennessee Titans | 95%
|
| AFC East Champ (3) | 11-5 | Miami Dolphins | 90%
|
| AFC West Champ (4) | 8-8 | San Diego Chargers | 90%
|
| NFC West Champ (4) | 9-7 | Arizona Cardinals | 80%
|
| NFC North Champ (3) | 10-6 | Minnesota Vikings | 80%
|
| NFC East Champ (1) | 12-4 | New York Giants | 80%
|
| NFC South Champ (2) | 12-4 | Carolina Panthers | 75%
|
| AFC Wild Card (5) | 12-4 | Indianapolis Colts | 75%
|
| AFC Wild Card (6) | 11-5 | Baltimore Ravens | 70%
|
| AFC (7) Missed Playoffs | 11-5 | New England Patriots | 65%
|
| NFC Wild Card (5) | 11-5 | Atlanta Falcons | 60%
|
| AFC (8) Missed Playoffs | 9-7 | New York Jets | 60%
|
| NFC Wild Card (6) | 9-6-1 | Philadelphia Eagles | 60%
|
| NFC (16) Missed Playoffs | 0-16 | Detroit Lions | 55%
|
| AFC (11) Missed Playoffs | 7-9 | Buffalo Bills | 45%
|
| AFC (14) Missed Playoffs | 4-11-1 | Cincinnati Bengals | 45%
|
| AFC (15) Missed Playoffs | 4-12 | Cleveland Browns | 45%
|
| AFC (9) Missed Playoffs | 8-8 | Houston Texans | 45%
|
| AFC (13) Missed Playoffs | 5-11 | Jacksonville Jaguars | 45%
|
| NFC (7) Missed Playoffs | 9-7 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 45%
|
| NFC (8) Missed Playoffs | 9-7 | Dallas Cowboys | 40%
|
| AFC (10) Missed Playoffs | 8-8 | Denver Broncos | 40%
|
| AFC (16) Missed Playoffs | 2-14 | Kansas City Chiefs | 40%
|
| AFC (12) Missed Playoffs | 5-11 | Oakland Raiders | 40%
|
| NFC (15) Missed Playoffs | 2-14 | St. Louis Rams | 40%
|
| NFC (9) Missed Playoffs | 9-7 | Chicago Bears | 35%
|
| NFC (13) Missed Playoffs | 6-10 | Green Bay Packers | 35%
|
| NFC (11) Missed Playoffs | 8-8 | New Orleans Saints | 35%
|
| NFC (14) Missed Playoffs | 4-12 | Seattle Seahawks | 35%
|
| NFC (10) Missed Playoffs | 8-8 | Washington Redskins | 35%
|
| NFC (12) Missed Playoffs | 7-9 | San Francisco 49ers | 30%
|