| Jersey Number | Position | Primary Team(s) | NFL player | Percent of NFL expert vote | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | QB | Green Bay Packers | Brett Favre | 100% | 95%
|
| 2 | QB | Atlanta Falcons | Matt Ryan | 78% | 92%
|
| 12 | QB | New England Patriots | Tom Brady | 100% | 92%
|
| 9 | QB | New Orleans Saints | Drew Brees | 100% | 89%
|
| 18 | QB | Indianapolis Colts | Peyton Manning | 100% | 89%
|
| 16 | QB | San Francisco 49ers | Joe Montana | 100% | 88%
|
| 13 | QB | Miami Dolphins | Dan Marino | 100% | 87%
|
| 20 | RB | Detroit Lions | Barry Sanders | 89% | 86%
|
| 21 | CB | Falcons/Cowboys | Deion Sanders | 100% | 86%
|
| 22 | RB | Dallas Cowboys | Emmitt Smith | 100% | 85%
|
| 7 | QB | Denver Broncos | John Elway | 100% | 85%
|
| 11 | WR | Arizona Cardinals | Larry Fitzgerald | 100% | 85%
|
| 17 | QB | San Diego Chargers | Philip Rivers | 89% | 83%
|
| 1 | QB | Houston Oilers | Warren Moon | 89% | 83%
|
| 8 | QB | San Francisco 49ers | Steve Young | 56% | 81%
|
| 32 | RB | Cleveland Browns | Jim Brown | 100% | 79%
|
| 79 | T | New York Giants | Rosey Brown | 89% | 79%
|
| 23 | KR/PR | Chicago Bears | Devin Hester | 89% | 76%
|
| 52 | LB | Baltimore Ravens | Ray Lewis | 100% | 73%
|
| 34 | RB | Chicago Bears | Walter Payton | 100% | 73%
|
| 84 | WR | Minnesota Vikings | Randy Moss | 100% | 71%
|
| 15 | QB | Green Bay Packers | Bart Starr | 100% | 69%
|
| 99 | DE | Houston Texans | J.J. Watt | 45% | 69%
|
| 56 | LB | New York Giants | Lawrence Taylor | 100% | 69%
|
| 87 | TE | New England Patriots | Rob Gronkowski | 78% | 68%
|
| 80 | WR | San Francisco 49ers | Jerry Rice | 100% | 67%
|
| 19 | QB | Baltimore Colts | Johnny Unitas | 100% | 67%
|
| 31 | FB | Green Bay Packers | Jim Taylor | 89% | 66%
|
| 88 | TE | Kansas City Chiefs | Tony Gonzalez | 56% | 66%
|
| 14 | QB | Cleveland Browns | Otto Graham | 56% | 62%
|
| 29 | RB | Los Angeles Rams | Eric Dickerson | 100% | 61%
|
| 43 | S | Pittsburgh Steelers | Troy Polamalu | 89% | 61%
|
| 75 | DT | Pittsburgh Steelers | Joe Greene | 56% | 60%
|
| 36 | RB | Pittsburgh Steelers | Jerome Bettis | 100% | 59%
|
| 54 | LB | Dallas Cowboys | Randy White | 56% | 59%
|
| 92 | DE | Eagles/Packers | Reggie White | 100% | 59%
|
| 10 | QB | Minnesota Vikings | Fran Tarkenton | 100% | 58%
|
| 30 | RB | Denver Broncos | Terrell Davis | 100% | 58%
|
| 91 | LB | Los Angeles Rams | Kevin Greene | 89% | 57%
|
| 28 | RB | St. Louis Rams | Marshall Faulk | 78% | 57%
|
| 71 | T | Seattle Seahawks | Walter Jones | 100% | 55%
|
| 24 | DB | Denver Broncos | Champ Bailey | 56% | 54%
|
| 42 | S | San Francisco 49ers | Ronnie Lott | 100% | 54%
|
| 59 | LB | Carolina Panthers | Luke Kuechly | 56% | 53%
|
| 81 | WR | San Francisco 49ers | Terrell Owens | 56% | 51%
|
| 6 | P | Los Angeles Rams | Johnny Hekker | 56% | 49%
|
| 51 | LB | Chicago Bears | Dick Butkus | 100% | 47%
|
| 69 | DE | Minnesota Vikings | Jared Allen | 100% | 47%
|
| 90 | DE | Carolina Panthers | Julius Peppers | 89% | 47%
|
| 55 | LB | San Diego Chargers | Junior Seau | 100% | 47%
|
| 26 | DB | Pittsburgh Steelers | Rod Woodson | 89% | 47%
|
| 89 | TE | Chicago Bears | Mike Ditka | 89% | 46%
|
| 78 | T | Cincinnati Bengals | Anthony Muñoz | 89% | 45%
|
| 73 | G | Dallas Cowboys | Larry Allen | 56% | 45%
|
| 35 | DB | Cardinals/Rams | Aeneas Williams | 67% | 44%
|
| 40 | RB | Chicago Bears | Gale Sayers | 89% | 40%
|
| 33 | QB | Washington Redskins | Sammy Baugh | 56% | 40%
|
| 27 | S | Denver Broncos | Steve Atwater | 56% | 40%
|
| 57 | LB | New Orleans Saints | Rickey Jackson | 56% | 36%
|
| 50 | LB | Chicago Bears | Mike Singletary | 100% | 35%
|
| 74 | OL | Oilers/Titans | Bruce Matthews | 45% | 34%
|
| 39 | RB | Miami Dolphins | Larry Csonka | 100% | 32%
|
| 93 | DT | Minnesota Vikings | John Randle | 67% | 30%
|
| 47 | DB | Pittsburgh Steelers | Mel Blount | 100% | 29%
|
| 58 | LB | Pittsburgh Steelers | Jack Lambert | 67% | 28%
|
| 44 | RB | Washington Redskins | John Riggins | 89% | 27%
|
| 25 | WR | Oakland Raiders | Fred Biletnikoff | 67% | 24%
|
| 95 | DE | Chicago Bears | Richard Dent | 100% | 23%
|
| 00 (discontinued) | C | Oakland Raiders | Jim Otto | 100% | 22%
|
| 41 | FB | San Diego Chargers | Lorenzo Neal | 89% | 22%
|
| 3 | FB | Chicago Bears | Bronko Nagurski | 89% | 21%
|
| 5 | HB/FB | Green Bay Packers | Paul Hornung | 100% | 21%
|
| 83 | LB | Oakland Raiders | Ted Hendricks | 100% | 21%
|
| 94 | DE/LB | 49ers/Cowboys | Charles Haley | 89% | 19%
|
| 63 | G | Oakland Raiders | Gene Upshaw | 56% | 19%
|
| 98 | DE | Indianapolis Colts | Robert Mathis | 78% | 19%
|
| 85 | DE | Los Angeles Rams | Jack Youngblood | 67% | 18%
|
| 60 | C/LB | Philadelphia Eagles | Chuck Bednarik | 89% | 16%
|
| 96 | DT | Seattle Seahawks | Cortez Kennedy | 100% | 16%
|
| 53 | LB | New York Giants | Harry Carson | 89% | 16%
|
| 82 | WR | Baltimore Colts | Raymond Berry | 56% | 16%
|
| 48 | FB | Dallas Cowboys | Daryl Johnston | 89% | 15%
|
| 64 | G | Minnesota Vikings | Randall McDaniel | 78% | 15%
|
| 66 | LB | Green Bay Packers | Ray Nitschke | 89% | 15%
|
| 68 | G | Kansas City Chiefs | Will Shields | 78% | 15%
|
| 86 | DT | Kansas City Chiefs | Buck Buchanan | 89% | 11%
|
| 97 | LB | Buffalo Bills | Cornelius Bennett | 56% | 11%
|
| 37 | RB/DB | Detroit Lions | Doak Walker | 56% | 11%
|
| 45 | S | Seattle Seahawks | Kenny Easley | 56% | 10%
|
| 77 | RB | Chicago Bears | Red Grange | 67% | 10%
|
| 72 | T | St. Louis Cardinals | Dan Dierdorf | 67% | 9%
|
| 61 | LB | Chicago Bears | Bill George | 56% | 8%
|
| 65 | T | Vikings/Broncos | Gary Zimmerman | 67% | 8%
|
| 76 | T/C/DT/K | Cleveland Browns | Lou Groza | 56% | 7%
|
| 70 | LB | Giants/Redskins | Sam Huff | 67% | 7%
|
| 62 | C | Miami Dolphins | Jim Langer | 89% | 6%
|
| 46 | TE | Los Angeles Raiders | Todd Christensen | 56% | 6%
|
| 38 | QB | Green Bay Packers | Arnie Herber | 89% | 5%
|
| 49 | RB/WR | Browns/Redskins | Bobby Mitchell | 89% | 5%
|
| 67 | G | Miami Dolphins | Bob Kuechenberg | 78% | 5%
|