| Team | Position | Year | American League Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York Yankees | Outfielder | 2025 | Aaron Judge | 100%
|
| Minnesota Twins | Catcher | 2009 | Joe Mauer | 100%
|
| Houston Astros | Second baseman | 2017 | Jose Altuve | 100%
|
| Detroit Tigers | First baseman/DH | 2013 | Miguel Cabrera | 100%
|
| Boston Red Sox | Outfielder | 2018 | Mookie Betts | 100%
|
| Los Angeles Angels | Pitcher/DH | 2023 | Shohei Ohtani | 100%
|
| Baltimore Orioles | Shortstop | 1991 | Cal Ripken Jr. | 91%
|
| Kansas City Royals | Third baseman | 1980 | George Brett | 91%
|
| Seattle Mariners | Outfielder | 2001 | Ichiro Suzuki | 91%
|
| Texas Rangers | Outfielder | 2010 | Josh Hamilton | 91%
|
| Toronto Blue Jays | Third baseman | 2015 | Josh Donaldson | 82%
|
| (Oakland) Athletics | Shortstop | 2002 | Miguel Tejada | 73%
|
| Chicago White Sox | First baseman/DH | 2020 | José Abreu | 64%
|
| Cleveland Guardians (Indians) | Third baseman | 1953 | Al Rosen | 45%
|