| Artist | Album | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| #1: American Football | American Football | 92%
|
| #33: American Football | American Football | 92%
|
| #4: Sunny Day Real Estate | Diary | 42%
|
| #22: Marietta | Summer Death | 37%
|
| #2: The Brave Little Abacus | Just Got Back From the Discomfort—We're Alright | 32%
|
| #29: Origami Angel | Somewhere City | 29%
|
| #3: The Brave Little Abacus | Masked Dancers: Concern in So Many Things You Forget Where You Are | 27%
|
| #5: Cap'n Jazz | Burritos, Inspiration Point, Fork Balloon Sports, Cards in the Spokes, Automatic Biographies, Kites, Kung Fu, Trophies, Banana Peels We've Slipped On and Egg Shells We've Tippy Toed Over | 23%
|
| #13: Sunny Day Real Estate | Sunny Day Real Estate | 22%
|
| #31: This Town Needs Guns | Animals | 19%
|
| #16: This Town Needs Guns | Animals Acoustic | 19%
|
| #9: Mineral | EndSerenading | 18%
|
| #6: Sunny Day Real Estate | How It Feels to Be Something On | 18%
|
| #7: Mineral | The Power of Failing | 18%
|
| #50: Chinese Football | Chinese Football | 15%
|
| #20: Texas Is the Reason | Do You Know Who You Are? | 14%
|
| #37: Glocca Morra | Just Married | 14%
|
| #15: The Promise Ring | Nothing Feels Good | 14%
|
| #25: Algernon Cadwallader | Some Kind of Cadwallader | 14%
|
| #27: Jets to Brazil | Orange Rhyming Dictionary | 12%
|
| #8: The Newfound Interest in Connecticut | Tell Me About the Long Dark Path Home | 12%
|
| #19: The World Is a Beautiful Place & I Am No Longer Afraid to Die | Whenever, If Ever | 12%
|
| #24: Empire! Empire! (I Was a Lonely Estate) | What It Takes to Move Forward | 10%
|
| #12: Penfold | Amateurs and Professionals | 8%
|
| #35: Braid | Frame & Canvas | 8%
|
| #28: Snowing | I Could Do Whatever I Wanted If I Wanted | 8%
|
| #17: Death Cab for Cutie | We Have the Facts and We're Voting Yes | 6%
|
| #39: Christie Front Drive | Christie Front Drive | 5%
|
| #30: Crash of Rhinos | Distal | 5%
|
| #11: Owen | At Home With Owen | 4%
|
| #45: Owls | Owls | 4%
|
| #10: On the Might of Princes | Where You Are and Where You Want to Be | 4%
|
| #44: Deer Leap / The World Is a Beautiful Place & I Am No Longer Afraid to Die | Are Here to Help You | 3%
|
| #47: Benton Falls | Fighting Starlight | 3%
|
| #34: Strictly Ballroom | Hide Here Forever | 3%
|
| #26: The Jim Yoshii Pile-Up | It's Winter Here | 3%
|
| #46: Rainer Maria | Look Now Look Again | 3%
|
| #18: The Appleseed Cast | Low Level Owl: Volume I | 3%
|
| #36: The Appleseed Cast | Low Level Owl: Volume II | 3%
|
| #21: The Appleseed Cast | Mare Vitalis | 3%
|
| #14: The Van Pelt | Sultans of Sentiment | 3%
|
| #43: Knapsack | This Conversation Is Ending... Starting Right Now | 3%
|
| #40: Edaline | I Wrote the Last Chapter for You | 1%
|
| #38: The Appleseed Cast | Two Conversations | 1%
|
| #23: Pretend | Bones in the Soil, Rust in the Oil | 0%
|
| #42: Boys Life | Departures and Landfalls | 0%
|
| #41: Elliott | False Cathedrals | 0%
|
| #48: The Appleseed Cast | Peregrine | 0%
|
| #32: Uchu Conbini | Somaru Oto wo Kakunin Shitara | 0%
|
| #49: Young Jesus | The Whole Thing Is Just There | 0%
|