Garden-Path or Invalid Sentence?

Each of the following is either a “garden-path sentence” (a sentence that is purposely obtuse) or an invalid sentence.
HINT: there are twice as many valid sentences.
Quiz by
Dimby
Rate:
Last updated: October 12, 2023
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedOctober 12, 2023
Times taken66
Average score71.4%
Report this quizReport
3:00
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
1. The old man the boat.
Valid
Invalid
2. The boat sank the river went by.
Valid
Invalid
3. The miserable creep eerily tonight.
Valid
Invalid
4. A pocket watch the show begins.
Valid
Invalid
5. The walking path bending the river.
Valid
Invalid
6. The complex houses married and single soldiers.
Valid
Invalid
7. The dog flea bitten jumped up.
Valid
Invalid
8. The pedestrian bridges the gap.
Valid
Invalid
9. The florist sent the flowers was pleased.
Valid
Invalid
10. The youth shop employee the discounts.
Valid
Invalid
11. The man who hunts ducks out on weekends.
Valid
Invalid
12. The hairy buffalo the clean shaven.
Valid
Invalid
13. The movie proceeds go to seating.
Valid
Invalid
14. The coin thrown well wishing.
Valid
Invalid
15. That Grandpa’s always here matters.
Valid
Invalid
16. The boat sailed under the bridge collapsed.
Valid
Invalid
17. The Greek bust the statues.
Valid
Invalid
18. The women bolted the window laid a trap.
Valid
Invalid
19. The beauty shops around town for deals.
Valid
Invalid
20. Flute maintenance and playing tricks the mind.
Valid
Invalid
21. Fat people eat accumulates.
Valid
Invalid
Save Your Stats
Your Next Quiz
How many countries do you know? In this quiz, you've got 15:00 to name as many as you can. Go!
Can you guess the 50 most populous cities in the United States according to 2024 U.S. Census estimates?
Can you guess each country based on three one-word clues?
Can you name the ten Asian countries with the largest GDPs?
5 Comments
+2
Level 88
Oct 12, 2023
Love it! Really fun. Bit tight on time.

I went valid on a "A pocket watch the show" thinking pocket could be used to mean a group of people. What do you think?

A large crowd is gathered. A pocket watch the show. The rest are on their phones.

(And I felt like the Bob one needed a comma to be valid but I guess comma use is debatable!)

+1
Level 63
Oct 12, 2023
The pocket explanation you gave makes sense (I got the question as intended). I also thought the comma was missing in the boat and flowers questions. If commas were added to the dog flea question, then it would be valid.

Love the quiz idea and the time was perfect for me.

+2
Level 83
Oct 12, 2023
Good points. Switched up the Bob question and included another very confusing one. The pocket one of course is a difference between British and North American English. I changed it up anyway, though.
+1
Level 63
Mar 3, 2024
(This is the wrong quiz, but I couldn't find the original quiz.) I remember on one quiz W was counted as a vowel because it forms a diphthong with O in "town". From what I read online, it seems like W in that instance would be a glide, which the article calls only partly a vowel. So would it still be valid to call W a vowel there?
+2
Level 83
Mar 3, 2024
That’s from the Stupidest Quiz on JetPunk. Most sources I’ve seen says that when w is paired with a, e, or o that it does act as a vowel to form a diphthong.