| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "Your hair is different. I like it." | Damon Salvatore | 98%
|
| "Caroline you and me is not going to happen." | Stefan Salvatore | 96%
|
| "It's natural to feel abandoned, I just don't want you to feel alone." | Carol Lockwood | 95%
|
| "You got Tannered. Been there." | Elena Gilbert | 94%
|
| "Wow Vicki Donovan says no. That's a first." | Tyler Lockwood | 94%
|
| "I got the other brother I hope you don't mind." | Caroline Forbes | 92%
|
| "Ugh who is this guy? Safari Sam?" | Niklaus 'Klaus' Mikaelson | 92%
|
| "It's okay Mr. Tanner. I'm good." | Matt Donovan | 89%
|
| "He has a romance novel sticker." | Bonnie Bennett | 88%
|
| "You have my word that I will pardon you." | Elijah Mikaelson | 85%
|
| "That sounds like the start of a love story Stefan, not the end of one." | Katherine Pierce | 83%
|
| "You look like a full-grown alpha male douchebag." | Alaric Saltzman | 82%
|
| "Tick Tock goes the gym clock." | Rebekah 'Bekah' Mikaelson | 74%
|
| "Iv'e become my worste nightmare. The authority figure." | Jenna Sommers | 72%
|
| "I miss you too friend." | Alexia 'Lexi' Branson | 55%
|