| Movie | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| A Streetcar Named Desire; Viva Zapata!; Julius Caesar; On the Waterfront; Sayonara | Marlon Brando | 96%
|
| The African Queen; The Caine Mutiny | Humphrey Bogart | 90%
|
| East of Eden; Giant | James Dean | 80%
|
| High Noon | Gary Cooper | 78%
|
| The Lavender Hill Mob; The Bridge on the River Kwai | Alec Guinness | 76%
|
| The King and I | Yul Brynner | 76%
|
| Harvey | James Stewart | 74%
|
| Richard III | Laurence Olivier | 71%
|
| From Here to Eternity | Burt Lancaster | 69%
|
| Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Paul Newman | 65%
|
| The Man with the Golden Arm | Frank Sinatra | 64%
|
| Father of the Bride; Bad Day at Black Rock; The Old Man and the Sea | Spencer Tracy | 64%
|
| Marty | Ernest Borgnine | 59%
|
| Sunset Boulevard; Stalag 17 | William Holden | 59%
|
| Sands of Iwo Jima | John Wayne | 56%
|
| The Robe | Richard Burton | 55%
|
| Separate Tables | David Niven | 54%
|
| A Place in the Sun; From Here to Eternity | Montgomery Clift | 54%
|
| Twelve O'Clock High | Gregory Peck | 53%
|
| Champion; The Bad and the Beautiful; Lust for Life | Kirk Douglas | 51%
|
| The Defiant Ones | Sidney Poitier | 51%
|
| Giant | Rock Hudson | 50%
|
| The Defiant Ones | Tony Curtis | 46%
|
| Cyrano de Bergerac; Moulin Rouge | José Ferrer | 44%
|
| Witness for the Prosecution | Charles Laughton | 43%
|
| A Star Is Born | James Mason | 41%
|
| Love Me or Leave Me | James Cagney | 39%
|
| All the King's Men | Broderick Crawford | 37%
|
| The Country Girl | Bing Crosby | 36%
|
| Death of a Salesman | Fredric March | 31%
|
| Wild Is the Wind | Anthony Quinn | 28%
|
| Bright Victory | Arthur Kennedy | 14%
|
| Robinson Crusoe | Dan O'Herlihy | 13%
|
| The Hasty Heart | Richard Todd | 13%
|
| A Hatful of Rain | Anthony Franciosa | 12%
|
| The Magnificent Yankee | Louis Calhern | 6%
|