| Sport | Years Active | Country | Hint | Athlete | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bodybuilding | 1968-1980 | 2000s Californian governor | Arnold Schwarzenegger | 80%
| |
| Wrestling | 1966-1992 | "Giant" who starred in "The Princess Bride" | Andre the Giant | 75%
| |
| Tennis | 1986-2006 | Married Steffi Graf | Andre Agassi | 67%
| |
| Auto Racing | 1984-1994 | They had one of the fiercest rivalries | Ayrton Senna | 66%
| |
| Tennis | 2005- | Only male British Wimbledon champion | Andy Murray | 59%
| |
| Football | 2005- | Green Bay Packers quarterback | Aaron Rodgers | 52%
| |
| Tennis | 1969-1980 | Only 3x black male tennis champion | Arthur Ashe | 52%
| |
| Ice Hockey | 2001- | Washington Capitals' "Ovi" | Alex Ovechkin | 48%
| |
| Soccer | 2001- | Scored the 2010 World Cup finals goal | Andrés Iniesta | 48%
| |
| Soccer | 1993-2012 | Greatest Ukrainian footballer? | Andriy Shevchenko | 47%
| |
| Soccer | 2009- | Wears No. 7 in Atlético Madrid | Antoine Griezmann | 45%
| |
| Soccer | 1988-2006 | Has the most goals in Premier League | Alan Shearer | 42%
| |
| Soccer | 2005- | Top goalscorer of the Chile national team | Alexis Sánchez | 42%
| |
| Auto Racing | 1980-1991 | They had one of the fiercest rivalries | Alain Prost | 41%
| |
| Golf | 1954-2006 | Namesake of a drink | Arnold Palmer | 41%
| |
| Basketball | 1996-2011 | Known as "The Answer" | Allen Iverson | 38%
| |
| Basketball | 1997-2015 | Has an assault rifle as his nickname | Andrei Kirilenko | 33%
| |
| Golf | 1992-2008 | Won the most pro female tournaments | Annika Sörenstam | 33%
| |
| Boxing | 2013- | He defeated Wladimir Klitschko in 2017 | Anthony Joshua | 30%
| |
| Short-track speed skating | 2001-2010 | Most decorated American Winter Olympian | Apolo Ohno | 19%
|