| Clue | Letter | City | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mexican resort city on the Yucatan peninsula | C | Cancún | 93%
|
| This city's Trenchtown neigborhood is the birthplace of the music genre reggae | K | Kingston | 91%
|
| Was catastrophically affected by a devastating earthquake in 2010 | P | Port-au-Prince | 89%
|
| Rihanna was born near this world capital | B | Bridgetown | 80%
|
| It's not the capital of Newfoundland and Labrador, but Antigua and Barbuda | S | Saint John's | 80%
|
| Site of the oldest permanent settlement of the European countries | S | Santo Domingo | 79%
|
| Belmopan replaced it as the nation's capital due to hurricanes | B | Belize City | 76%
|
| Northernmost city in Colombia that is Shakira's home town | B | Barranquilla | 74%
|
| Costa Rican city whose name is Spanish for "lemon" | L | Limón | 74%
|
| Capital named after the patron saint of England | S | Saint George's | 73%
|
| Namesake of a major lake, actually an ocean bay | M | Maracaibo | 47%
|
| "Orange city" of either Aruba or Sint Eustatius | O | Oranjestad | 44%
|
| Home to the biggest stock exchange in the Caribbean | P | Port of Spain | 44%
|
| City whose "Moncada Barracks" were attacked by Fidel Castro in 1953 | S | Santiago de Cuba | 44%
|
| Capital of the U.S. Virgin Islands | C | {Charlotte} Amalie | 33%
|
| Resort town at the eastern tip of Hispaniola | P | Punta Cana | 33%
|
| Guatemalan town named for a famous Scottish missionary and explorer | L | Livingston | 32%
|
| Was founded in 1650 as "Carenage" by the French | C | Castries | 29%
|
| Located at the northern terminus of the Panama Canal | C | Colón | 26%
|
| Formerly the main port for trade between Spain and its overseas empire | C | Cartagena | 25%
|