I agree that the Munich urban area has more than Stuttgart. I looked up the populations of Stuttgart and its main suburbs/attached towns, and it was only a million or so. I think they are including Heilbronn, Tübingen and Reutlingen, but there is a lot of countryside between those places and Stuttgart.
China should be Chongqing (31 m), Shanghai (24 m), Beijing (21 m), Chengdu (20 m) and Guangzhou (18 m). Xiamen is a rather small city with six million inhabitants.
Chengdu does appear to be more highly populated than Xiamen by any measure, according to multiple different web pages I found. (I've never been there, mind you.)
There’s a few different countries in this quiz where the quiz maker I think either has skewed or outdated Data or has classified the definition of what constitutes the boundary of an “Urban Area” as different than it actually is. Good quiz for the most part but that’s why you don’t use Wikipedia as a main source lol.
I would recommend not having both Brazil and Portugal since Porto Alegre and Porto overlap. Although I would guess most people who know Porto Alegre know Porto.
Not that it's that huge a deal, but in case this quiz gets some edits in the near future, the Syrian flag should be updated as well. Nice quiz to feature regardless!
Fantastic quiz, very challenging time constraints too, I think I wasted a bit too much time trying to do the first few country-by-country instead of just boxing off all the ones I knew immediately and then working on stragglers. Got 172/222; think I could've gotten that up to the 4-point boundary with better use of my time, some glaring omissions on my part from rushing towards the end (I got Coimbra and Kaohsiung but missed Gdansk and Innsbruck lol)
What's the source for Xiamen being the 5th major urban area in china?
As of today Feb.4th.2025 you mention citypopulation.de (which has different data) and wikipedia (which has different data - Xiamen is not even mentioned in the top 20 urban areas). And yes, I looked for urban areas, not city proper.
Honestly, it's pretty frustrating having to go through tenths of city names, since china has so many eligible cities, only because the definition is so loose, at least I hope this is the reason.
20 days later, increased my score by 10, didn't miss any that I got last time either so that's good progress. Still a couple here I should be remembering (Lausanne, Dnipro, and Stavanger spring to mind) but a lot of the others are just unknowns that I need to learn haha
How is Xiamen #5, I looked at Wikipedia and the source you mentioned and it’s urban/metro area isn’t even close to some other cities that weren’t on the list. Did you merge the two populations on accident? Please give me a better source so I can confirm that Xiamen is the fifth most populated urban area city in China.
You should add "Taizhong" as a spelling for Taichung. For those of us that know the name in Chinese, that is the most direct Latinized spelling (while you're at it add "Taibei" for Taipei).
Also, I agree with the other commenters, you are using a very odd definition of metro area for Xiamen to end up anywhere in the top 10 Chinese cities, let alone top 5. It's a pretty small city by Chinese standards. Honestly not even in the top 20 by most definitions of metro area. What list are you using?
Challenging quiz. I feel like a nice round 20 minutes would be better than 18, but perhaps that's part of the difficulty. Also, would you consider accepting "Antofogasta" for "Antofagasta"?
I don't understand how Boston is on this quiz. I understand its based on urban area, but I checked both Wikipedia and citypop and neither of them listed Boston as top 5 in urban population. I also noticed the urban area of Boston extends considerably into southern NH, almost into the town I'm from, which is a literal hour drive from the city.
Nitpicking aside, this is a great quiz :) Goes beyond the usual range of countries and also visually pleasing
Hamburg
Munich
Cologne (without Düsseldorf)
Frankfurt
would be the correct ranking for Germany.
As of today Feb.4th.2025 you mention citypopulation.de (which has different data) and wikipedia (which has different data - Xiamen is not even mentioned in the top 20 urban areas). And yes, I looked for urban areas, not city proper.
Honestly, it's pretty frustrating having to go through tenths of city names, since china has so many eligible cities, only because the definition is so loose, at least I hope this is the reason.
Also, I agree with the other commenters, you are using a very odd definition of metro area for Xiamen to end up anywhere in the top 10 Chinese cities, let alone top 5. It's a pretty small city by Chinese standards. Honestly not even in the top 20 by most definitions of metro area. What list are you using?