| Clue | Island | % Correct | |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | The Emerald Isle | Ireland | 97%
|
| I | Discovered by Vikings in 874 AD | Iceland | 96%
|
| M | Mediterranean island nation | Malta | 95%
|
| J | Bob Marley's island | Jamaica | 94%
|
| I | Spain's party island | Ibiza | 91%
|
| M | One of the five boroughs of NYC | Manhattan | 91%
|
| N | The world's smallest island country | Nauru | 90%
|
| L | Biggest island in New York | Long | 89%
|
| M | Largest island in the Indian Ocean | Madagascar | 89%
|
| J | English Channel island | Jersey | 87%
|
| N | Joined Canada in 1949 | Newfoundland | 86%
|
| J | World's most populous island | Java | 85%
|
| N | Otherwise known as Papua | New Guinea | 85%
|
| L | Greek island where Sappho lived | Lesbos | 83%
|
| N | Where Auckland and Rotorua are | North Island | 80%
|
| L | Main island of the Philippines | Luzon | 78%
|
| K | Volcanic island that erupted in 1883 | Krakatoa | 77%
|
| K | Florida island where Hemingway lived | Key West | 76%
|
| I | Where a U.S. flag was raised in WWII | Iwo Jima | 71%
|
| M | French island in the Caribbean | Martinique | 71%
|
| M | Portuguese autonomous island | Madeira | 68%
|
| J | First English settlement in America | Jamestown | 60%
|
| K | Southernmost of Japan's main islands | Kyushu | 60%
|
| K | Croatian island with no vowels | Krk | 59%
|
| K | Alaskan island / bear subspecies | Kodiak | 58%
|
| N | "There once was a man from..." | Nantucket | 57%
|
| I | Home to Odysseus | Ithaca | 56%
|
| J | Largest South Korean island | Jeju | 47%
|
| L | Largest of the Outer Hebrides | Lewis and Harris | 28%
|
| L | Indonesian island east of Bali | Lombok | 28%
|